Kendrick: "No matter what his color is, hip hop is hip hop and Eminem is one of the greatest"

Claudex

Lord have mercy!
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
6,239
Reputation
3,762
Daps
18,812
Reppin
Motherland
So you're right about Eminem being in his own lane. It's a lane that he only has because he's white. Yeah, I'm stuck on that point. Because it's true. He hasn't had to live under the same criteria and scrutiny as Jay and Nas. Black artists aren't allowed to express insecurity or they're ripped apart. Jay said he would not lose and Nas made an entire culture call him a "dikk sucking faggit" for it. Eminem talks about snowballing nut and nobody says a word.

I'd like one celebrity to say it out loud and not kiss his ass. Just one. I want to hear one rapper be honest and say "Eminem is a great lyricist, but nobody bumps a single album he's ever made where I'm from". How is Eminem a legend to a young kid from Compton? I don't buy it. Kendrick's saying it because he thinks he has to.

The bolded is the answer you're so intent in not seeing breh breh. Eminem being white has everything to do with his greatness. Why do you think his rap-style's "warped" (according to the song 'role model')? It's because his skin color, which affected his life in the ghetto, also required him to approach hip-hop from a different angle not travelled by any black rapper before.

The criteria for greatness is much larger than you seem to think it is. Is eminem the best? Hell no. But nobody can say that he didn't create a lane of his own, a lane that not even Macklemore/MGK/Mac Miller can travel through without being seen as fake. That's what it means to be great, to do something that nobody can recreate.
 

sporticus

https://bit.ly/36fn72e
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
2,375
Reputation
340
Daps
5,578
Reppin
NULL
The bolded is the answer you're so intent in not seeing breh breh. Eminem being white has everything to do with his greatness. Why do you think his rap-style's "warped" (according to the song 'role model')? It's because his skin color, which affected his life in the ghetto, also required him to approach hip-hop from a different angle not travelled by any black rapper before.

The criteria for greatness is much larger than you seem to think it is. Is eminem the best? Hell no. But nobody can say that he didn't create a lane of his own, a lane that not even Macklemore/MGK/Mac Miller can travel through without being seen as fake. That's what it means to be great, to do something that nobody can recreate.

Interesting angle.
 

Wacky D

PROVOCATIVE POSTING
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
40,578
Reputation
524
Daps
36,719
no surprise here.

a rapper with a 90% white fanbase pandering to his white audience by trying to boost his handler's legacy.

:beli:

There's a reason why Nas used the line "And Eminem killed you on your own shyt" on Ether. :mjpls:


also on that song, nas said "compared to beans you wack".

yet, ive never even seen beans crack a top 50 on any of these white folk rap lists.

:camby:
 

Colin X

Superstar
Joined
Jul 22, 2014
Messages
10,585
Reputation
-2,477
Daps
52,451
Reppin
Auburn
Yo... :ohhh:



A few weeks ago I had a dream about this thread. Same replies and same posters... :lupe:
 

Wacky D

PROVOCATIVE POSTING
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
40,578
Reputation
524
Daps
36,719
lol @ people taking rappers' cosigns to heart. most of them chits are not genuine. some are even paid for or instructed.

"bu bu but nas & jay said blah blah blah".

you dudes is stupid.

If em was Black and had the same exact skills he would be goat on coli, and lol @ comparing Nas to Eminem the same hoe who was scared to do a track with him cuz he'd get bodied


if eminem was black and had the same exact skillset, he would be ignored on the coli, just like all the other black rappers of his ilk that preceeded him.

be smart son.
 

SunZoo

The Legendary Super Sapien.
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
35,703
Reputation
13,139
Daps
136,689
Reppin
T.L.C.
Nas makes little noise in popular culture. People don't talk about him enough to take shots. Nas is a rap legend, so much so that everyone knows him, but he makes no noise on the pop charts. Make no mistake, I'd love to have his career, but he's not spoken of in the pop landscape. Little old grannies know Jay-Z and Eminem. They don't know Nas.

Grannies don't make diss records though. Nas is and will always be and icon within the culture regardless of how far his reach is outside of it. Those 3 names ring out when it comes to living legends/veterans. When Nas did decide throw his weight around on some superiority shyt he ended up getting hit with a flower pot :heh:

But he's been pretty humble and so is Eminem. Something that Jay is not (nor does he need to be)

It's because Jay Z is a mainstream icon by his own design. So yeah he's out there to attack. Who did Jay Z ever block from success tho? Of all the arguments leveled at Jay Z, that's always been the weakest. Whose shine and flow did he steal? We still acting like Young Chris was ever a thing? You're supposed to jump on hot tracks. Ask Drake. You're supposed to have hot features. You call it sticking your neck out, I call it remaining relevant.

Oh don't get me wrong, I don't criticize Jay for remaining relevant i'm just saying that he's in the mix. He's still trying (and succeeding) to dictate aspects of the culture and playing up to the trends that keep in him competition with everybody else. IE "death of auto tune"...unlike HHID as a commentary, he actually said "hey, stop making this type of song", or "hey, stop wearing this or that".

As for the flows...people have mentioned him kinda getting into two-chains pocket a couple times on MCHG, even M.I.A. which holds merit when you really listen and consider the strength of some of her records. He definitely adapts more current day raps into his style more than the other two, which has it's positives and negatives.Nas and Em do THEIR thing.

So you're right about Eminem being in his own lane. It's a lane that he only has because he's white. Yeah, I'm stuck on that point. Because it's true. He hasn't had to live under the same criteria and scrutiny as Jay and Nas. Black artists aren't allowed to express insecurity or they're ripped apart.

I disagree. especially when you consider that "emo rap" was really ushered into mainstream Hip Hop by 2pac. Which funnily enough is the only other person with sales comparable to Eminem. Him being white undoubtedly played a role in how inflated his sales are, but much like Pac, him being open about his insecurities and faults with his fans made him ENDEARING.

Nas and Jay aren't endearing to that degree. For the most part when the music cuts off they are out of sight out of mind...Pac and Eminem embodied the mindsets of the young black and white male in a way that made them sympathetic figures.

Now look at Kanye and all those he ushered in...nobody is ripping them apart for their insecurity as black artists. And if they are it hasn't stopped their success, critical acclaim or similar artists from popping up. I just think your bias keeps you from seeing the real in favor for harping on about "he's white doe!"

Jay said he would not lose and Nas made an entire culture call him a "dikk sucking faggit" for it. Eminem talks about snowballing nut and nobody says a word.

Correction, he called him a dikk riding faggit for his propensity to trend hop and stand next to nikkas who are poppin.

:sas2:

As for em saying gay stuff for shyts and giggles, nobody said a word when biggie did it either. When you come out and set a precedent (in the mainstream) for shock value and humor people will let you do your thing.

Jay couldn't get that type of shyt off any easier than em could get off raps about moving weight.

I'd like one celebrity to say it out loud and not kiss his ass. Just one. I want to hear one rapper be honest and say "Eminem is a great lyricist, but nobody bumps a single album he's ever made where I'm from".

Meek mill said this not to long ago (and this is after he sampled one of his records and bit his flows I mind you). He wasn't disrespectful about it he just kept it real, said he didn't listen to em's albums that much but respected his talent. Nothing wrong with that.

But what if that's not the case? It's weird how nikkas just assume that RAPPERS, especially ones that are lyrical wouldn't listen to one of the greatest lyricists in the mainstream....we not hearing from random goons who don't even have time to really get into Hip Hop like that beyond it being a backdrop for criminal activity...we talking about people who practice and probably study rappers to find out how to be a good one.

How is Eminem a legend to a young kid from Compton? I don't buy it. Kendrick's saying it because he thinks he has to.

I'm from the hood my nikka, I grew up in poverty, but I'm a Hip Hop head and used to rap a lil bit. The same cats that put me up on Eminem initially were hood nikkas who rapped as well.

I'm trying to figure out how growing up in Compton keeps Kendrick Lamar from thinking that Eminem is legendary...especially when early Eminem was joined at the hip with Dr. Dre and really apart of the lineage that gave birth to the west coast and all of it's legendary emcees.

Makes perfect sense to me regardless of how much it helps your talking points to conclude that it's 100% a PR move...dude is a rappers rapper.
 
Last edited:

sporticus

https://bit.ly/36fn72e
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
2,375
Reputation
340
Daps
5,578
Reppin
NULL
Grannies don't make diss records though. Nas is and will always be and icon within the culture regardless of how far his reach is outside of it. Those 3 names ring out when it comes to living legends/veterans. When Nas did decide throw his weight around on some superiority shyt he ended up getting hit with a flower pot :heh:

But he's been pretty humble and so is Eminem. Something that Jay is not (nor does he need to be)



Oh don't get me wrong, I don't criticize Jay for remaining relevant i'm just saying that he's in the mix. He's still trying (and succeeding) to dictate aspects of the culture and playing up to the trends that keep in him competition with everybody else. IE "death of auto tune"...unlike HHID as a commentary, he actually said "hey, stop making this type of song", or "hey, stop wearing this or that".

As for the flows...people have mentioned him kinda getting into two-chains pocket a couple times on MCHG, even M.I.A. which holds merit when you really listen and consider the strength of some of her records. He definitely adapts more current day raps into his style more than the other two, which has it's positives and negatives.Nas and Em do THEIR thing.



I disagree. especially when you consider that "emo rap" was really ushered into mainstream Hip Hop by 2pac. Which funnily enough is the only other person with sales comparable to Eminem. Him being white undoubtedly played a role in how inflated his sales are, but much like Pac, him being open about his insecurities and faults with his fans made him ENDEARING.

Nas and Jay aren't endearing to that degree. For the most part when the music cuts off they are out of sight out of mind...Pac and Eminem embodied the mindsets of the young black and white male in a way that made them sympathetic figures.

Now look at Kanye and all those he ushered in...nobody is ripping them apart for their insecurity as black artists. And if they are it hasn't stopped their success, critical acclaim or similar artists from popping up. I just think your bias keeps you from seeing the real in favor for harping on about "he's white doe!"



Correction, he called him a dikk riding faggit for his propensity to trend hop and stand next to nikkas who are poppin.

:sas2:

As for em saying gay stuff for shyts and giggles, nobody said a word when biggie did it either. When you come out and set a precedent (in the mainstream) for shock value and humor people will let you do your thing.

Jay couldn't get that type of shyt off any easier than em could get off raps about moving weight.



Meek mill said this not to long ago (and this is after he sampled one of his records and bit his flows I mind you). He wasn't disrespectful about it he just kept it real, said he didn't listen to em's albums that much but respected his talent. Nothing wrong with that.

But what if that's not the case? It's weird how nikkas just assume that RAPPERS, especially ones that are lyrical wouldn't listen to one of the greatest lyricists in the mainstream....we not hearing from random goons who don't even have time to really get into Hip Hop like that beyond it being a backdrop for criminal activity...we talking about people who practice and probably study rappers to find out how to be a good one.



I'm from the hood my nikka, I grew up in poverty, but I'm a Hip Hop head and used to rap a lil bit. The same cats that put me up on Eminem initially were hood nikkas who rapped as well.

I'm trying to figure out how growing up in Compton keeps Kendrick Lamar from thinking that Eminem is legendary...especially when early Eminem was joined at the hip with Dr. Dre and really apart of the lineage that gave birth to the west coast and all of it's legendary emcees.

Makes perfect sense to me regardless of how much it helps your talking points to conclude that it's 100% a PR move...dude is a rappers rapper.

You make extremely valid points and I think Eminem is massively talented. However, I don't consider ANY of his material worth a listen after his second album with the exception of about 3 songs. No exaggeration there either. Ironically, that homoerotic lyric I mentioned is from one of those three songs I actually like which is why I know it lol. So that's my feeling on a personal level.

So then my criticism is two-fold: motive and material. If hip-hop is a black artform with critieria for "legend" status being things I don't necessarily even agree with, where is the impetus for calling this man a legend if he doesn't fit that criteria? His songs make no urban noise or reach that demo. So who decided and what's the motive? Pharoah Monch and Talib Kweli is are technically proficient to beats and are both rapper's rappers. Nobody calls them legends.

So if Pharoah Monch and Talib Kweli are technically profient and "rapper's rappers" but aren't legends then what separates Eminem? Sales? Ok, why are the sales there? Yeah.......
 

MIAlien

#FactsOnly
Supporter
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
2,284
Reputation
420
Daps
4,565
Reppin
Wade County
Kendrick is right. Eminem is up there among the great. Eminem just can't be the greatest because he's the beneficiary of white privilege in Hip Hop.

Like Jay Z said about Eminem, "Look in the mirror, my only opponent."
 

SunZoo

The Legendary Super Sapien.
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
35,703
Reputation
13,139
Daps
136,689
Reppin
T.L.C.
You make extremely valid points and I think Eminem is massively talented. However, I don't consider ANY of his material worth a listen after his second album with the exception of about 3 songs. No exaggeration there either. Ironically, that homoerotic lyric I mentioned is from one of those three songs I actually like which is why I know it lol. So that's my feeling on a personal level.

I respect that :salute:

So then my criticism is two-fold: motive and material. If hip-hop is a black artform with critieria for "legend" status being things I don't necessarily even agree with, where is the impetus for calling this man a legend if he doesn't fit that criteria? His songs make no urban noise or reach that demo. So who decided and what's the motive? Pharoah Monch and Talib Kweli is are technically proficient to beats and are both rapper's rappers. Nobody calls them legends.

So if Pharoah Monch and Talib Kweli are technically profient and "rapper's rappers" but aren't legends then what separates Eminem? Sales? Ok, why are the sales there? Yeah.......

First let me say that in my view, legendary in the context of Hip Hop has degrees (aka there's levels to this shyt) and as someone who is into the mechanics of EMCEEING Talib (more so as apart of blackstar) and ESPECIALLY Monch are certainly legends.

Biz Markee is a legend to me, so when I see someone exclude Eminem from legendary status on some lets sandbag him because he sold too many records it just doesn't compute. I love this shyt though and respect these dudes and what they do and a lot of people just don't seem to see it like that. To a lot of folks sales and notoriety is the baseline...it's important to factor in at the end of the process when we are dealing with history books but it doesn't make you legendary anymore than a championship ring makes you better than Charles Barkley.

So I dig what you're saying, if the separation is just about sales you have to then put Em into proper context which is something I always bring up even though he's clearly one of my favorite emcees of all time. There is a middle ground between absolute GOAT and being one of the greats though. I think the problem lies with the competitive nature of Hip Hop we feel like to include this guy, you gotta remove another which is where the competitive spirit that drives the culture starts to do more harm than good.
 
Last edited:

sporticus

https://bit.ly/36fn72e
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
2,375
Reputation
340
Daps
5,578
Reppin
NULL
I respect that :salute:



First let me say that in my view, legendary in the context of Hip Hop has degrees (aka there's levels to this shyt) and as someone who is into the mechanics of EMCEEING Talib (more so as apart of blackstar) and ESPECIALLY Monch are certainly legends.

Biz Markee is a legend to me, so when I see someone exclude Eminem from legendary status on some lets sandbag him because he sold too many records it just doesn't compute. I love this shyt though and respect these dudes and what they do and a lot of people just don't seem to see it like that. To a lot of folks sales and notoriety is the baseline...it's important to factor in at the end of the process when we are dealing with history books but it doesn't make you legendary anymore than a championship ring makes you better than Charles Barkley.

So I dig what you're saying, if the separation is just about sales you have to then put Em into proper context which is something I always bring up even though he's clearly one of my favorite emcees of all time. There is a middle ground between absolute GOAT and being one of the greats though. I think the problem lies with the competitive nature of Hip Hop we feel like to include this guy, you gotta remove another which is where the competitive spirit that drives the culture starts to do more harm than good.

I feel you. Like you said originally, alot of it is absolute overcompensation for what is felt as unfair advantages as compared to black artists. I don't deny my bias there. When I think about it, I iif magine him disappearing off the face of the Earth after his first two albums, it changes my own perspective. Which tells me that it's alot less about his body of work and more about my view of it. So it's a personal thing, very subjective.
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
69,328
Reputation
14,001
Daps
96,389
Reppin
CHICAGO
...he's called Tech9 :ufdup:
:manny:


tech was never as dope as eminem.
he raps fast, but he was never as eye popping or as eye catching as eminem.
in a full gamut of skills like eminem.
nor, does he really have any appearances that are seeing the same early material eminem had till now, either.
he is more a styles era based emcee.
who, got full recognition from jimmy jam and terry lewis.
past that,...
i never saw tech on em's level.
tech nine, was more closely related to early mystikal, with the extension spice one braids.
before mystikal had a large visible presence in 94, and vids.
was close to what i would say tech nine is.
he was never as dope as eminem song to song.
plus, never as eye catching bar to bar.
past juice, and big L,....
i have not heard anyone that was that eye popping a talent in that time frame.
who was as consistent or culturally aware as eminem.

in 94-98, for people who never had a record deal.
i had not heard any one who consistently every appearance was as dope as juice and eminem.
tech nine in any incarnation was never that potent skillwise as em or ju.

i have no tech nine material i will put on.
i right now, can still travel in time and pull out definitive eminem appearances and verses.
taht still to this day,.....
really have no real equal.
when, compared to talent that was signed after eminem was picked up on the national battle an indie scene.

to this day,..
i never heard a tech nine release and said he was going to arguably be one of the greatest ever.
like, i did when i heard eminem's ssep and reviewed it on davey d.com

plus, at the time it was completely taboo.
to ever champion a white cat...
that is how next level content and technical skillwise eminem was in that era.
plus, eminem was the real deal.
as far as doing what a real emcee is supposed to do, and be skilled in.

plus, i can't say tech nine was ever as dope as eminem on biterphobia, or the actual album cut to infinite.
before eminem was forced to switch up and be his own emcee skillbase wise.


art barr
 
Top