If he shouldn’t be judged like any other player because of his age then his legacy building ended years ago and he’s a novelty act now.
His legacy building did end years ago. This is a point I've been hitting on...
His record was sealed already when he won in Cleveland, that was at Year 13. That stamped him as the greatest player of all time, and 13 years is the same amount of career Russell, Bird, Magic played, and the same amount of time Mike played in Chicago. Everything to validate him as the GOAT, was done in 13 years...
The 2016 Finals is by consensus regarded as the greatest Finals performance in basketball history. Led a comeback from 1-3. Did it vs the team with the most regular season wins ever. Led both teams in every traditional stat. Greatest defensive play in NBA history. Greatest 3-game stretch to close a Finals in NBA history. Iconic plays throughout the series...
He reached a level of play in that series that wasn't seen before then, and hasn't, yet, been seen since. Even for people who, it didn't make him the GOAT, it rocketed him forward, and keep in mind before then he was already considered Top 10, he already had two rings and 4 MVPs and dominated an era...
So for the people who it didn't make him the GOAT, the next benchmark that swayed some people, was the 2018 playoff run. That Cavs team was bad and he not only drug them to 50 wins in Year 15, he won 3 playoff series as an underdog in each series, and by consensus, his Game 1 of the 2018 Finals is viewed as one of the greatest games ever played----->adding to a career where he already has a number of greatest Finals games ever played...
That was thru 15 years, Mike's entire career, and that '18 playoff run and G1 Finals swayed some people...
Then he came to LA, but let's be honest and be clear. Most of us who thinks he's the GOAT thought he was BEFORE he got here, he'd played a full, 15-year career before he ever put on a Laker jersey. Myself, he could've retired after '16 and the conversation was over with. So everything he's done since has enhanced his case, and to me you can't go down as you age because it's not like it can erase what we saw in his first 15 years...
The fact is that coming to LA in his age-34, Year 16 season, coincided with his aging and decline. He had the first major injury of his career, and that trend has held throughout his Laker run
because he was fukking old when he got here. He never lost a Rd1 series before becoming a Laker, never got hurt before becoming a Laker, both these things have amplified with his age...
He still won a title in Year 17 and that swayed some people. Some have been swayed by still being a Top 10-ish player in his late 30s and winning the All-Time scoring title at Year 20. Since winning his last title though, it's been more injuries, another missed playoff, 3 Rd1 losses (the first 3 of his career). If you're someone who has never thought he was the GOAT, this hurts him...
My response to that would be, keep it consistent and tell me the players who you felt legacies were impacted in their 18th, 19th, 20th, 21st, 22nd seasons. If you did this with everyone who played forever, fine. But we know you didn't and no one else did, either. We have never given a fukk about what guys are doing at ages they traditionally suck, and while Bron doesnt "suck", he has never been tge same player after popping his groin in December 2018, that he was before. Even when they won in '20, that was a diminished version of him, still great enough to win a title, but that wasn't peak LeBron James...
He's never been the same since the Y16 injury and that should be okay, people are supposed to get worse with age, and he has, no different than anyone else. The only difference is while he's gotten worse, his "worse" has still been better than everyone else's worse as they aged, and yall mf's grade him differently because of it...
He was the greatest player of All-Time before he came to this poorly run franchise. Public perception of his legacy is being altered because you nikkas act like his first 15 years never happened. I wish he retired years ago, he is a novelty act now and he shouldn't be judged the same way as all these guys still creating and shaping their legacies, his has been set for years...