Lets settle this once and for all: Randall Cunningham or Michael Vick?

RhodyRum

Mark Gassed-A-Heaux
Joined
May 16, 2013
Messages
9,301
Reputation
5,670
Daps
42,266
Reppin
The Great Green North
:rudy:
Save for the SB, he's been big for them, he did all he could w/ no receivers and idiot coaching.
Both are HoF'ers, but Prime McNabb is an elite qb, just a slight notch over McNair.

McNair as a HOF'er is a stretch

:upsetfavre: McNabb > McNair

I thought there'd be more love for McNair both as the GOAT black QB and him being a natch above McNabb. Normally I'm a stat geek but I'm too damn "Friday lazy" to do any statistical comparisons. McNair to me seemed like he was in more control of his O and just had a bit more raw-bit gumption and a steelier belly for the crunch time (no pun /jab at the McVomit incident btw). Just my opinion. What are ya'll arguments for McNabb > McNair?
 
Top