It was okay, but not great. The aesthetics of the 60s Kirby/Lee quirkiness was excellent. There's some elements of the early comics that work. But A LOT of the plot beats were rehashed from Rise of the Silver Surfer.
Sue Storm was great, and Vanessa Kirby played it well. Shallah Bal was good too. The rest of the cast were a mixed bag. First off, Reed. Pascal was pretty bland, and he definitely isn't Reed Richards. Or I'll say I didn't like the portrayal of Reed...the writers don't get the character...maybe the internal hidden monologue, but not the demeanor, the actions, the outward personality. Ben was cool, but not enough, and Johnny didn't have the personality. Much of the chemistry needed wasn't there. Oh yeah, Galactus is another that doesn't really work in an action movie.
So, you put Vanessa Kirby's Sue in the Tim Story F4 movies, and you have something...at least with the cast. But once again, they don't do anything. AT this point, just keep them in space, Family Robinson style. I don't think there'll ever be a great F4 movie. It was okay for what it was.
Sue Storm was great, and Vanessa Kirby played it well. Shallah Bal was good too. The rest of the cast were a mixed bag. First off, Reed. Pascal was pretty bland, and he definitely isn't Reed Richards. Or I'll say I didn't like the portrayal of Reed...the writers don't get the character...maybe the internal hidden monologue, but not the demeanor, the actions, the outward personality. Ben was cool, but not enough, and Johnny didn't have the personality. Much of the chemistry needed wasn't there. Oh yeah, Galactus is another that doesn't really work in an action movie.
So, you put Vanessa Kirby's Sue in the Tim Story F4 movies, and you have something...at least with the cast. But once again, they don't do anything. AT this point, just keep them in space, Family Robinson style. I don't think there'll ever be a great F4 movie. It was okay for what it was.



seems like this is really goood tho, from the few posts I read.