MBDTF: 10th Anniversary Thread

Is My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy a classic?

  • Yes

    Votes: 53 86.9%
  • No

    Votes: 8 13.1%

  • Total voters
    61
  • Poll closed .

TheGodling

Los Ingobernables de Sala de Cine
Joined
May 21, 2013
Messages
20,078
Reputation
5,608
Daps
70,616
Reppin
Rotterdam
This is one subject I'm willing to debate. Show me a more sonically progressive album. Show me an album that broke creative boundaries like this album.
I forgot it all about this shyt argument. This album singlehandedly birthed "sonically" as the go-to argument to excuse albums that weren't lyrically strong or had other obvious flaws (and was almost exclusively used for Kanye's music).

'Sure Kanye regressed horribly as a rapper but sonically this shyt just hits different.' :ohlawd:

Clown-ass KTT talking points. :heh:
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,977
Reputation
4,119
Daps
49,566
Reppin
NULL
I forgot it all about this shyt argument. This album singlehandedly birthed "sonically" as the go-to argument to excuse albums that weren't lyrically strong or had other obvious flaws (and was almost exclusively used for Kanye's music).

'Sure Kanye regressed horribly as a rapper but sonically this shyt just hits different.' :ohlawd:

Clown-ass KTT talking points. :heh:

This.

That argument was the biggest push for MBDTF being one of the best albums ever. Sonically, that album took pieces from each of his previous albums and combined them into one album. That's the album's strength and weakness. Its a weakness because at some points, it sounds like all of these elements clashing together instead of being in harmony with each other.

But yeah, there are several albums that were far more progressive than Kanye's MBDTF.
 

SnowflakesByTheOZ

Sorry, that's another B
Joined
Feb 12, 2017
Messages
13,887
Reputation
3,465
Daps
57,186
I forgot it all about this shyt argument. This album singlehandedly birthed "sonically" as the go-to argument to excuse albums that weren't lyrically strong or had other obvious flaws (and was almost exclusively used for Kanye's music).

'Sure Kanye regressed horribly as a rapper but sonically this shyt just hits different.' :ohlawd:

Clown-ass KTT talking points. :heh:
I asked you to list a more sonically progressive album.

Will you list one or are you too busy deflecting ?
 

Switch

All Star
Joined
Nov 9, 2014
Messages
2,747
Reputation
433
Daps
9,220
This is one subject I'm willing to debate. Show me a more sonically progressive album. Show me an album that broke creative boundaries like this album.

Can you explain how it’s the GOAT album without using buzz words you picked up from album reviews on the internet?
 

SnowflakesByTheOZ

Sorry, that's another B
Joined
Feb 12, 2017
Messages
13,887
Reputation
3,465
Daps
57,186
Can you explain how it’s the GOAT album without using buzz words you picked up from album reviews on the internet?
I don't even read reviews but deflect away sir. I already gave you 2 predominant reasons as to why I have the opinion I do. Yall quoting me and doing everything else but naming albums lol.
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,977
Reputation
4,119
Daps
49,566
Reppin
NULL
I asked you to list a more sonically progressive album.

Will you list one or are you too busy deflecting ?

Albums that are more sonically progressive than Kanye's:

Aquemini
Stankonia
Miss E... So Addictive
Hell Hath No Fury
Speakerboxxx/Love Below
To Pimp A Butterfly
 
Top