More Impressive: Havocs production at 18 vs Nas writing Illmatic at 18

More impressive?

  • Havoc

    Votes: 22 21.8%
  • Nas

    Votes: 79 78.2%

  • Total voters
    101

BrothaZay

Non-FBA. AdosK
Bushed
Supporter
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
64,615
Reputation
6,163
Daps
222,290
Reppin
The suburbs
Beats came from samples, Nas literary work came from scratch. and Yes, I called it literary:stopitslime:

my vote, Nas.
The samples is what makes the beats that much more impressive. If I gave you havocs samples and told you to go remake Shook Ones or Survival of the Fittest you'll be looking at me crazy.
 

BrothaZay

Non-FBA. AdosK
Bushed
Supporter
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
64,615
Reputation
6,163
Daps
222,290
Reppin
The suburbs
I'll take Nas, barely.

But more than anything, realizing the contributions these guys made to the culture at 18 years old, makes me feel like I'm living an underwhelming life :shaq2: :wow:
True. TBH I was going to include Pac and Cube in this poll as well.
We forget Pac wrote some of the most power hip hop songs around the same age as well. But you really gotta give Cube his place in history for what he wrote for NWA when he was only like 16 :wow:
 

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
63,327
Reputation
9,765
Daps
210,836
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
The samples is what makes the beats that much more impressive. If I gave you havocs samples and told you to go remake Shook Ones or Survival of the Fittest you'll be looking at me crazy.
Yea. Hav was unbelievable with his flipping skills but like I said he was coached by some of the best. That's not a knock on him tho. Still one of the best hip hop producers ever imo. I would just pick Nas in this particular comparison.
 

Jack Skellington

yes indeed family
Joined
Aug 27, 2015
Messages
1,768
Reputation
0
Daps
6,413
Reppin
Halloween Town
The samples is what makes the beats that much more impressive. If I gave you havocs samples and told you to go remake Shook Ones or Survival of the Fittest you'll be looking at me crazy.

I hear you bruh, but anybody that has tried to venture into anything creative knows that creating something good from scratch is incredibly hard. Having samples to play around with is a great deal of help. Not to knock what Havoc did, he made some great instrumentals, shook ones is actually my favourite beat of all time:obama:
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
68,914
Reputation
13,880
Daps
96,039
Reppin
CHICAGO
Wasn't Nas hanging out with Paid in Full posse in his early years?


Nas is from queens.
They re from Harlem and a whole two cultural gens removed from nas.
They are three sonic landscapes changes from nas as a debut artist as well.
Plus, azie and his guys were never proficient emcees at all.
They were the equivalent of some guys like I can do what nwa was on and from some real shyt perspective not a Hollywood perspective like nwa.

Best thing about azie and his guy's music was the sonic presentation, mixing and engineering.

Art Barr
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
68,914
Reputation
13,880
Daps
96,039
Reppin
CHICAGO
Not to sound like a stan but I think it's silly to try and discredit Havoc because he was "mentored" by other producers.
You gotta remember this was early 90s music production. Long before a wannabee producer can just download FL studios for free and look at tutorials on youtube, and start making beats laying down with your laptop in your lap. You had to actually invest in hundreds, maybe thousands of dollars of HARDWARE. All in a time period where the mim wage was like $3.00. So it's only logically that if you wanted to produce during that time, find a big homie or someone who already has everything since you can't afford it, and naturally they'll give you a few pointers as well just out of love since you are using their equipment.


In this regard, you talembout the guy who ushered in the whole technical emcee revolution as standard in all of the culture.
To usher out the b*stardized and overly commercial and compromised styles war era.
So, you can't give havoc more credit than nas at all.
As nas, did this on his own and Continued to build on.
how to be a feature artist that excels from skill output in the business of rap.

Havoc, again was qtip and blackmoon/evil dee protege.
Plus socially hav was just more social in the projects than nas as well.
As all the other emcees never socially was gracious to nas and had negative jealous views about the kid that created disconnect.
Or they needed a new record deal and had to get an avatar to fakin jax with using a voice over talent to make it.
So, nas was alone in his development as an emcee.
Plus, after big L, the next evolution of skill for the hardcore bboy era that ushered out the styles war era.
Nas was that much better than anyone who was on his level.
Or a guy like big l, Redman, percee p, k solo, jeru, doc.
who were viewed as the guys who pushed the skills of emcee'n by an unknown feature on posse cuts to obscene levels of greatness.
Plus, when you listen to the enfamous.
you can hear the native tongues qtip influence. all throughout the release in every aspect of the entire album.
As mobb deep is pretty much q tip's cultural answer.
to people saying new York rap needed to come.
from a first person cowboy edict damning perspective like westcoast gangsta rap.


Art Barr
 

SirBiatch

Prince of Persia. Stalked for daps
Joined
Feb 18, 2015
Messages
25,121
Reputation
-20,651
Daps
39,905
Nas. He was on a whole other skill level from anyone else around him, regardless of age. To the point that even by 95, people still hadn't caught up to him. I was bumping Cuban Linx a while back and it ocurred to me that Rae and Ghost's rhyme styles sounded a tad basic compared to Illmatic. and Illmatic was done in a good year and a half before them.

Hav was nice. But there were other producers like Premo, Large, RZA, Tip who were just as nice.
 
Top