NBA Rank top 10 Center's ever

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
43,494
Reputation
-102
Daps
90,651
Im not understanding why Shaq is being rated so low...


I mean...

Did anybody see him play? This nikka was flat out unstoppable

Shaq's ranking has more to do with the men in front of him then Shaq himself.

I wouldn't of minded seeing him 3, but 4 is great considering who's in front of him
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
83,057
Reputation
25,736
Daps
373,395
Why would any of the centers from this era be on the list, when their careers aren't even close to being over? :jbhmm:
Nobody in the last 21 years is even close to being top 20 at the center position. That's enough time for someone to have asserted themselves.

Guys like Shaq and Robinson aren't part of that.
 

FTBS

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
20,767
Reputation
3,718
Daps
56,823
Reppin
NULL
Im not understanding why Shaq is being rated so low...


I mean...

Did anybody see him play? This nikka was flat out unstoppable

By who? The list got him at 4 and everyone in here has him top 4 or 5. You want him over guys that have more hardware and/or even bigger numbers? Other guys dominated too you know.
 

ItWasWritten

Superstar
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
10,438
Reputation
1,590
Daps
28,499
Reppin
The Scriptures
By who? The list got him at 4 and everyone in here has him top 4 or 5. You want him over guys that have more hardware and/or even bigger numbers? Other guys dominated too you know.

Shaq would destroy russell b lets be honest...

I love what russell did but that was different era full of a lot of white men ...

I guess if we are going by just accomplishments then fine but nobody in the history of the league is seeing a prime Shaq to me
 

Malta

Sweetwater
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
66,896
Reputation
15,180
Daps
279,751
Reppin
Now who else wanna fukk with Hollywood Court?
Nobody in the last 21 years is even close to being top 20 at the center position. That's enough time for someone to have asserted themselves.

Guys like Shaq and Robinson aren't part of that.

Dwight will go down as a top 20 center, and I don't like him one bit.


Yao would have been a top 15 center had it not been for the injuries :yeshrug:



Joel Embiid has the potential to be one of the ATG if his body holds up.
 

FTBS

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
20,767
Reputation
3,718
Daps
56,823
Reppin
NULL
Shaq would destroy russell b lets be honest...

I love what russell did but that was different era full of a lot of white men ...

I guess if we are going by just accomplishments then fine but nobody in the history of the league is seeing a prime Shaq to me


Shaq had the talent and the teammates to keep it from even being a conversation. There are no excuses for him.
 

Anerdyblackguy

Gotta learn how to kill a nikka from the inside
Supporter
Joined
Oct 19, 2015
Messages
64,227
Reputation
18,501
Daps
356,270
Those wilt chamberlain numbers :whoo:

30 pts per game
22 rebounds per game
 

Goatpoacher

Superstar
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
8,355
Reputation
575
Daps
16,079
By who? The list got him at 4 and everyone in here has him top 4 or 5. You want him over guys that have more hardware and/or even bigger numbers? Other guys dominated too you know.

Center is one of the most decorated positions, sure, but once again the problem is defining what makes player X better or worse than player Y. Tracy Mcgrady at his peak was better than Ray Allen, but Ray Allen had a better overall career. Do we give Russell credit for sacrificing his own stats for the sake of his team?

I tend to fixate on "impact" which I admit is fairly nebulous itself. I also like to distinguish a player's peak performance from his overall performance. For example, D Rose before the injuries was a top 3 PG easily. Base on "peak performance" and "impact" Shaq from 99 to 2003 was possibly even more valuable than Jordan
 
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
232
Reputation
20
Daps
638
Reppin
NULL
I think this is the fairest list they did. Minor complaints like Mikan being on it over Willis Reed or Artis Gilmore, but historically I see why they did it. You could really put 2-6 in any order. (Kareem is the GOAT) I'd probably swap Shaq and Russell but that's just nitpicking.
 

TrebleMan

Superstar
Joined
Jul 29, 2015
Messages
5,592
Reputation
1,190
Daps
17,546
Reppin
Los Angeles
Going with Shaq.
The 6 Toughest Players I've Ever Guarded | By Nazr Mohammed

Taking away his move meant not giving him a dunk, which of course is setting your defensive bar pretty low. It also meant sacrificing your body by trying to stop a 320+ pound man from getting to his sweet spot on the court.

In order to guard him, or at least attempt to guard him, you had to do your work early. That meant getting back on defense quickly and trying to meet him at the free throw line. From there, you’d basically brace yourself for impact in a collision that you were physically incapable of winning.

When he was younger, you were able to double team him on the catch. Problem is, he got used to that over the years and eventually became a good passer. Then it came down to just hoping he missed the shot or using one of your fouls to make him earn points at the line.

Shaq was the most dominant big man I’ve ever faced. He’s in a class of his own.

Honestly, Shaq could have earned a foul call on pretty much every play of his career. I mean, the only way to guard the guy was to either push or hold him, which was usually considered a foul. It’s almost like he was being punished for being stronger than his opponents. If a defender stood in there and took the hit, he could draw the foul on Shaq. Sometimes being the loser in a battle for position was rewarded.

But refs couldn’t call games with Shaq the same way they called other games. They just couldn’t. Opposing teams would have fouled out all of their big men by the middle of the second quarter.

When I saw him on the schedule, my main goal was to just not let him dunk the ball.

That was it.
 
Last edited:
Top