Prime Dwyane Wade, 2004-13 (9 years)
He was a #1 for 5 years in his prime, 2005-10. With #1 responsibilities, he played an average of 66.6 games/year, we remember him not being the most durable baller but he was more available than not...
In 5 years, again this is Prime Wade, with #1 burden, he led Miami to an average of 40.2 wins/year, 1-0 Finals, 1-0 ECF, 3x Rd1 out, missed playoffs in '08...
That '06 title saves him but it's the anomaly of Wade's tenure as a #1 option. Shaq came to Miami and took them from fringe playoff team to instant contenders, as soon as he fell off a cliff Wade never put them in contention.......until another GOAT level player came to Miami...
This is my problem with Wade. They weren't even contenders when he didnt have Shaq and Bron. Don't tell me about who he had to run with, that '08 season is inexcusable, Miami was 10-41 in the games he played. In '07 he missed 23 games late in the season and Miami went 16-7, going from below .500 to 8 games over and making the playoffs. They amped up without him...
When he basically fully healthy in '09 he took them to 43 wins and a Rd1 loss to.......the dominant, overwhelming Atlanta Hawks. In '10 they improved to 47 wins but didn't improve in seeding and won just one playoff game...
Miami was never a contender with him when he didnt have Shaq or Bron. He did typically raise his level of play I'm the postseason so that and the '06 title run give him the ultimate trump card over Harden. But he wasn't better at basketball than Harden and I have no clue why people just eliminate results in his career ('07, '08, being unable to contend without Shaq and Bron, etc). His resume as a #2, in prime, is what super inflates him ('05, '11, '12, '13)...
As a #2 he played 70.8 games/year (more durable as a #2 because it was a more natural role for him), Miami went to 4 ECFs in those 4 years, 3 Finals, 2 titles. The Heat won 60 games/year in the 4 years of Wade's prime, that he was a #2. He has an argument as greatest #2 ever depending on the criteria, because he was a 23 point scorer as a #2 and had a few huge "step up" moments...
If Wade had a season or two that he kept Miami in contention post-Shaq, pre-Bron, I'd get it. But he didn't, Miami won without him when he missed time, he wasn't moving the needle other than being an exciting player. Imagine Harden having a season his team goes from out the playoffs in well inside when he misses 23 games...
Imagine Harden having a season his team is 10-41 in the games he plays...
Imagine Harden playing 5 years as a #1 in the weaker conference and never being able to win 50 games unless a Top 10 All-Timer is with him...
This is why Wade is overrated. The results don't match the reputation. The results show me he was very dependent on who played with him, Harden was carrying Houston into contention for with mid rosters, mid coaching, and no Top 10 All-Timer with him, disadvantages that, when Prime Wade was faced with the same, his team was garbage...
This is the guy yall overrate the shyt out of. I don't even need to touch the 2011 Finals. Dwyane Wade really was not That Guy...