Meh. In the case of last night, I don't think that matters. Br*dy has made an entire career, millions of dollars, married a supermodel, and called GOAT by "going for the short underneath stuff more often than not". If you can strike downfield with accuracy at the right time, like Smith did last night, that is not a sinI was watching last night in the 1st half and he passed up some short passes to air it but he was still going for the short underneath stuff more often than not


The fact that it took Mahomes to make Alex pass downfield would make me want him gone even more.![]()
All different QB's can win in this league, and you don't need to be throwing down the field constantly to win games.
Obviously not since the Chiefs are one of the more successful teams in the NFL over the past couple years but you need to threaten teams over the top consistently which Smith simply doesn't do enough.
I mean, the Chiefs themselves spent two first rounders and a third on Mahomes. If they thought Smith was getting them to the promised land, are they doing that?
It's one gameI'd take him against Brady
and my fellow raiders, Carr ain't tha answer!![]()



You obviously didn't watch the game last night
Smith has been relatively nice for a minute now. At least top half of the league.
RyanI'd even say in a group of better than over half of league. Like top 40 percent if he keeps playin like that.

he made that comment in '16 brehIt's one game
Alex Smith is better then Tom Brady now
This thread is dumb as hell and insults my intelligence
id take him over big ben...dude is one more concussion away from being a vegetable imoRyan
Rodgers
Brady
Wilson
Winston
Brees
Carr
Roethlisberger
Those are the only QBs I have over him clearly. There's another 5-6 that are on his same level that I wouldn't be mad at ranking over him, but he slick has a case for top 10 I would take today, depending on how good my defense is