Making beats doesn't mean you produced the song though. In a lot of cases, the person who makes the "beat" simply programmed drums. Someone else played guitar, strings, and keyboards etc. The producer is the person who puts it all together ensuring that it sounds like one cohesive piece. Otherwise, it could sound like one big mess.
Liner notes often reveal this fact. The person who produced the song doesn't necessarily have to manually create a beat. There's a lot of people who make beats and erroneously label themselves producers. Yes, they probably made the beat, but they aren't there with the artist to create the song. They made the beat with no regard for the artist. That's why you have these disgruntled beat makers who get mad when they get placements on big albums and didn't receive production credits. They didn't get production credits because a real producer has to step in and do what the beat maker didn't do. They have to ensure that everything is in harmony (the vocals and the instruments). Sometimes, the producer will have to entirely re-do the track to get the sound that they want. They add and subtract things, but may keep the overall vibe the same.
Liner notes often reveal this fact. The person who produced the song doesn't necessarily have to manually create a beat. There's a lot of people who make beats and erroneously label themselves producers. Yes, they probably made the beat, but they aren't there with the artist to create the song. They made the beat with no regard for the artist. That's why you have these disgruntled beat makers who get mad when they get placements on big albums and didn't receive production credits. They didn't get production credits because a real producer has to step in and do what the beat maker didn't do. They have to ensure that everything is in harmony (the vocals and the instruments). Sometimes, the producer will have to entirely re-do the track to get the sound that they want. They add and subtract things, but may keep the overall vibe the same.

Kanye was breathing all through his verses 



@ OP not being convinced when Pac and Suge said it, but being all
when NORE says it 