OFFICIAL Game of Holmes Season 8 Thread - A Dream of Flat Tops 4/14/19

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

I DIDNT SAY ANY OF THAT.
DONT KNOW IF YOURE TROLLING OR DENSE...

WHEN EVERYTHING SETTLED
AND IT WAS TIME FOR DANY TO RULE
SHE WAS GONNA COME TO CLAIM THE NORTH ALSO...

GIVEN THE WAY THEY HAVE REACTED TOWARDS HER WITH JONS COSIGN
THEY WOULD HAVE SUFFERED THE SAME FATE AS THE SOUTHERNERS.



​

Nah you're being dense, acting like Jon bent the knee to spare them of Dany's wrath. Who knows what happens after the great war. Dany may not even survive. Her dragons may not have even survived. And if they did and she did threaten to rain fire, Jon could have bent the knee like Torren Stark did centuries ago AFTER the war. He cleary bent it out of love just as Sansa said.

You've been all over the place trying to explain it way. First you tried to claim he did as some "honorable" act to make up for her losing her dragon to save his life, now you're claiming he did it to spare the lives of northerners after the great war

 

[NatiboyB]

CAN SOMEONE hook me up with the leak i need to see episode 2.

 

[Trajan]

Also Euron Greyjoy gotta be one of the funniest motherfukkers in this show

He hit Cersei with the Tevin Campbell can we talk

 

[NatiboyB]

i've bookmarked the posts of people "looking" for a link to leaked episodes, i'm snitching on and negging any one of yall i see come back in a few days with a "new theory" that "just so happened to pop in your head"

I won't do that...But yes I'm trying to see them early I got to go to the field for a month I just want to see the next episode.

 

[The_Unchosen_One]

All this bickering and the army of the dead is marching towards us!!!

 

[42 Monks]

Please do explain how you think things would have played out if she had told Jon. I already explained that if Ramsey knew the Vale was in the fold he would have never left castle and they had enough provisions to endure a multiyear siege.

It's unlikely that Jon would have heeded Sansa's advice (he explicitly stated she didn't know shyt about war tactics), however even if she was able to convince him to keep the Vale in his back pocket, do you really think that changes anything? Does Jon not go charging in to save Rickon in your version of events? Jon has gotten by with braun, but he does a lot of dumb shyt. From forcing his men to charge in after him (after Davos explicitly stated they had stay back cuz they were outnumbered) to getting Viserion killed so he could slay 10 more wights. I don't know why you're acting like Jon deserved to be trusted with that information. He either fukks it up bringing them in to early or things play out the same as they did.

so its either she's a dumbass or she was ready to let jon die

sansa set, which is it

hating on jon's feats at this point is a disgrace too. that's the one dude you tell, ride with, and trust in the whole show...

 

[detroitwalt]

Bro no one alive anywhere in the known world in this series has experience fighting dragons. What happens when those elephants catch fire to the face, panic, and start crushing the GC's own men?

You making up your own argument. Breh asked why Cersei would want elephants and I said why. I didn't say they would be effective against dragons.

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

so its either she's a dumbass or she was ready to let jon die

sansa set, which is it

hating on jon's feats at this point is a disgrace too. that's the one dude you tell, ride with, and trust in the whole show...

She told Jon Ramsay would try to lure him into a trap and not fall for it....Jon proceeds to fall for it.

Jon himself acknowledged how much smarter Sansa's become, yet some of y'all still in denial

 

[Sinnerman]

I forgot how quickly this thread moves

I'm always four pages behind

 

[Sinnerman]

I haven't followed y'alls argument, but from what I'm reading I don't get how people are surprised/upset by how Sansa is being portrayed

In both the books and the show it's clear she's being "groomed" for a post-war administrative role.

 

[42 Monks]

She told Jon Ramsay would try to lure him into a trap and not fall for it....Jon proceeds to fall for it.

Jon himself acknowledged how much smarter Sansa's become, yet some of y'all still in denial

she told him common sense. amazing what an elite strategist

such a bold plan goes hand in hand with openly questioning him at every meeting while its obvious that the banners fall in behind him and only tolerate her as the secretary

even when she gets tools, she can't use them - they use her

I haven't followed y'alls argument, but from what I'm reading I don't get how people are surprised/upset by how Sansa is being portrayed

In both the books and the show it's clear she's being "groomed" for a post-war administrative role.

yeah she can use her excellent horse counting skills for the future generations meanwhile cersei bought a whole army and on her third victory lap, dany took a whole country, and arya survived the worst of the world with nothing but a goon's mentality. I guess she's slightly better than Brienne but that's debatable.

 

[The Prince of All Saiyans]

 

[dora_da_destroyer]

thread has gone off the rails and it's only tuesday

cats dissecting every minute thing about sansa and asking about war elephants vs dragons...wtf

 

[duck]

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

she told him common sense. amazing what an elite strategist

such a bold plan goes hand in hand with openly questioning him at every meeting while its obvious that the banners fall in behind him and only tolerate her as the secretary

even when she gets tools, she can't use them - they use her

If it was common sense and Jon still got fooled by it, what does it say about Jon?