Well is the walking dead an open world game?  That game is basically a point and click game.  mass effect 2? Lol that's an RPG game and TLOU is a wide linear game.
		
		
	 
twd is a choice based click and play -- so how does it have more replayability and higher ratings than a game like infamous? 

  mass effect series is barely a RPG, it's basically a 3rd person shooter w/better options. and yes, TLou is a linear game, but somehow it took me longer to beat LoU than it did infamous. 
if we wanna go sandbox for sandbox, it took me longer to beat gta v and sleeping dogs. why wont y'all dudes just humble yourselves and admit the game was a bit limited in the campaign. seems like suckerpunch focused more on powers and lightning over the campaign, do you agree with that?