Paul George or Carmelo Anthony?

[Miggs]

Chandler couldnt average 20 for a whole series.

i wouldnt call them the same players

He dont need too...defend the paint and rebound which is what he does...
Hibberts not a 20 ppg scorer either,what your seeing this year is about what he is which is what Chandler does when healthy...

 

[Jplaya2023]

Chandler = Hibbert

lol i'd like to see chandler dominate the cheat like hibbert did last year

 

[cleanface coney]

He dont need too...defend the paint and rebound which is what he does...
Hibberts not a 20 ppg scorer either,what your seeing this year is about what he is which is what Chandler does when healthy...

i see what you sayin...but idk man...i think if it came down to it you can give Hibbert the ball if you need a bucket

Chandler not so much...

 

[Miggs]

lol i'd like to see chandler dominate the cheat like hibbert did last year

He wont ever dominate offensively...Hibbert did what most big men can do against Miami,hes not a 20/10 player and without Miami hes not averaging 17...Hes a 12/10 type player.

 

[Miggs]

i see what you sayin...but idk man...i think if it came down to it you can give Hibbert the ball if you need a bucket

Chandler not so much...

Hibberts off game is better and he will most likely average more PPG generally speaking they do the same things and you want the same things from them...defense,protect the rim and rebounding.

Game on the line Pacers aint going to Hibbert with the ball either...

 

[GreatestLaker]

Please tell me what center on the knicks is as good as Hibbert

What PF is as good as West

Luis Scola would be starting on the Knicks.

Put PG on the Knicks with the same players they currently have and yall nikkas tune would be totally different. Word is bond

Stop acting like we haven't seen Carmelo play with all-star talent before. Are you forgetting his Denver teams? Teammates have nothing to do with it. Melo has never been this good. George does everything better than Melo except for scoring.

 

[GreatestLaker]

Last night was the first time I actually saw Paul George give a SUPERSTAR performance. In the 4th qtr and OT, dude took over and said I ain't letting my team lose. I'm sold. Paul George is officially a top 5 player in my book.

Last night was the first time you watched him play. George been doing this. PG passed Melo last year.

 

[toooldforthisship]

3rd best player in the league tbh. People always sleep on the importance of Defense. PG can legit lock down 3 positions & even defend some 4s. His jumper is a lot better this year as well. Is Melo even top 10 this year?

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Melo at his best has not played as well as PG is right now

 

[Bone$]

P George a problem

 

[YoungMoneyCashMoneyBoy]

Not a good year for the kingdom of new york. Another out of towner comes through and becomes king of new york.

kendrick lamar
king george

The "mecca" of flabby and sick rap and basketball

 

[Rob's al Ghul]

http://espn.go.com/nba/story/_/page/5-on-5-131120/wednesday-espn-doubleheader-edition

2. George or Melo: Whom would you rather build your team around?
Elhassan: George, but it's a lot closer than one might think. Anthony has caught a lot of flak in recent years for not being the type of player who can elevate his teammates, but if he were surrounded by the right personnel, he could be a devastating force. I choose George because his ability to impact the game in categories other than scoring gives a team a lot more flexibility in the type of supporting cast it can put around him.

Harper: In a vacuum in which both players are the same age and have the same contract, I'd still take Melo because I'm a big believer in building your team around an offensive focus (like the Mavs did with Dirk). However, basketball exists in TV sets, not a vacuum. I'll take George because of the two-way play and his youth.

Pina: George. He's a 23-year-old phenomenon, able to take over games with a pterodactyl wingspan on offense and defense. For those who hark back to Carmelo Anthony's sensational scoring ability, George is averaging 2.4 fewer points per game on 4.5 fewer shots. His PER and true shooting percentage are both higher, but George's real value comes when his team needs a stop -- something that will never be said about Anthony, who's also six years older.

Stein: Who's younger? More importantly: Who's by far the better two-way player? Crazy as this might have sounded in November 2012, who could vote against Paul George at this stage?

Windhorst: George. It's not a completely fair question since George is 23 and Melo is 29. You're talking to one of George's bigger supporters in the media here, and the reason I've been impressed with him is his ability to play both ends. He's also focused on being a team-first guy, sometimes to a fault where he needs to take on a more commanding role. Melo is a truly amazing scorer, but no one will ever accuse him of being a team-first guy or a dedicated defender.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Stop acting like we haven't seen Carmelo play with all-star talent before. Are you forgetting his Denver teams? Teammates have nothing to do with it. Melo has never been this good. George does everything better than Melo except for scoring.

A few of those Denver teams were actually good, not all of them.

Unfortunately, the Lake Show, Pheonix, Spurs, and Utah were all popping....The west was a flat out beast.

All of his Knicks squad have been trash

 

[Mr. Jack Napier]

Ya'll overrating the hell out of Paul George, for real though.

 

[Hollywood Co]

Doug Collins called PG a top 10 player last night and its hard to argue. 35 plus points while guards Melo and holding to a terrible FG percentage.

Its PG right now and its looking like it may stay that way.