Peyton Manning STILL has a better playoff passer rating than Tom Brady

[ill]

This is what, your 3rd thread on Peyton> Brady? How's it working out for you?

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

last SB winning season for Brady, 2004.

Last SB winning season for Manning 2006


Seriously breh, whats your fukking point here? 2 years difference and yet u bashing brady for it and not Peyton.

The difference is, one is more recent than the other

Peyton won his SB in 2007 just to be exact. He's been to the same amount of SB's (2) and won one more than Brady in that same period, where both were the centerpiece of the team

Seems like Brady is the only QB in the goat discussion never to win a ring in his prime

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

This is what, your 3rd thread on Peyton> Brady? How's it working out for you?

It's working out like this

Only people in the new england region think Brady is better, and we all know the coli is full of smart-dumb nikkas who go against the grain for the hell of it. So I get to slay fools daily

 

[ill]

Peyton Manning 1998-2013 (16th season) - 1 SB Ring
Tom Brady 2000-2013 (14th season) - 3 SB Rings

Let me put this into a "time frame" for you to understand. Brady has played two LESS seasons and has two MORE rings than your idol. Get over Peyton already. He's a great QB and 2nd best. But the GOD is Brady so quit your blasphemy.

 

[Bboystyle]

The difference is, one is more recent than the other

Peyton won his SB in 2007 just to be exact. He's been to the same amount of SB's (2) and won one more than Brady in that same period, where both were the centerpiece of the team

Seems like Brady is the only QB in the goat discussion never to win a ring in his prime

this makes no sense at all. You are being selective here in what time periods to judge the two. Anyone can use that logic and compare the two from their first 5 years as a starter in this league and then the competition wouldnt be close. So what that Peyton has one ring in the past 7 years. Brady won his rings early in his career while Peyton had to wait to win his. That doesnt mean shyt at all. By your logic, Eli >> Peyton

 

[ill]

It's working out like this

Only people in the new england region think Brady is better, and we all know the coli is full of smart-dumb nikkas who go against the grain for the hell of it. So I get to slay fools daily

The Coli hates anything and everything CAC and Boston related. Bad comparison.

 

[ill]

And quoting a SportsNation poll? Really bruh. Thats the most bandwagon shyt ever. Peyton is favored cuz he is tearing up the league right now and putting up 50 points a game. Have this poll in 2007 when Brady was doing that and Brady would win that poll in a landslide.

 

[Bboystyle]

It's working out like this

Only people in the new england region think Brady is better, and we all know the coli is full of smart-dumb nikkas who go against the grain for the hell of it. So I get to slay fools daily

Breh im unbias towards both QB's and to tell u the truth i rather have my current QB then either brady or manning. With that being said, if i were to choose a QB to go with in crunch time i'd go Brady over manning easily.

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

Breh im unbias towards both QB's and to tell u the truth i rather have my current QB then either brady or manning. With that being said, if i were to choose a QB to go with in crunch time i'd go Brady over manning easily.

Thats fine and dandy, your vote can go in with the other 40% that voted for Brady

I'm sure the majority 60% would be happy with Peyton

 

[ill]

Peyton Manning 1998-2013 (16th season) - 1 SB Ring
Tom Brady 2000-2013 (14th season) - 3 SB Rings

Let me put this into a "time frame" for you to understand. Brady has played two LESS seasons and has two MORE rings than your idol. Get over Peyton already. He's a great QB and 2nd best. But the GOD is Brady so quit your blasphemy.

@O RLY Care to address this with all your time frame arguments

 

[ill]

Wait, is @O RLY really Jim Irsay? He's the only person in this world thats ever ridden Peytons dikk so hard...

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

@O RLY Care to address this with all your time frame arguments

Terry Bradshaw has more rings than Tom Brady

Joe Flacco has more rings than Dan Marino

Stanleys use the same tired argument.


How many rings has Brady won in his prime when he had to do something besides ride other peoples coattails?

Now stop mentioning me and triple posting, we know you're furious already

 

[ill]

Terry Bradshaw has more rings than Tom Brady

Joe Flacco has more rings than Dan Marino

Stanleys use the same tired argument.


How many rings has Brady won in his prime when he had to do something besides ride other peoples coattails?

Now stop mentioning me and triple posting, we know you're furious already

1) Bradshaw is an all time great

2) Joe Flacco sucks. No one considers him a top QB so its pointless to bring him into an arguement over two of the greatest QBs ever.

3) You're the one thats using rings as a fukking argument. "Oh Brady has none in the last 10 years but Peyton has 1" So when I state some facts about your rings argument you sit there and spin it in Peytons favor lol

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

1) Bradshaw is an all time great

2) Joe Flacco sucks. No one considers him a top QB so its pointless to bring him into an arguement over two of the greatest QBs ever.

3) You're the one thats using rings as a fukking argument. "Oh Brady has none in the last 10 years but Peyton has 1" So when I state some facts about your rings argument you sit there and spin it in Peytons favor lol

1) Plea Copped

2) Pedal Backed

3) noted

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

It's working out like this

Only people in the new england region think Brady is better, and we all know the coli is full of smart-dumb nikkas who go against the grain for the hell of it. So I get to slay fools daily

This nikka posted a SB poll to prove his point.

If you ever tracked these polls, they change like the seasons. Fans are fickle and they sway towards whoever has the sexier numbers at the moment. This same poll is asked every year and Brady won it in other years.