Peyton Manning STILL has a better playoff passer rating than Tom Brady

[TNC]

Brady owns Peyton
Eli owns Brady
Peyton owns Eli

Rock beats Scissors
Scissors beats Paper
Paper beats Rock

 

[Lakers Offseason]

I said they haven't won any titles since the D slipped even though Brady stepped into the elite class. In other words, the D, led by Belichick, was more important than Tom Brady.

Wasn't that your question?

True story. Every SB game the D has let the opposing team come back and tied it. Brady has had to comeback and lead his team to a game winning score for the 3 SBs they won.

On the SB loses, Brady has led his team to TD drives within 3 minutes of both games only for the D to blow it.
The SB loss Peyton orchestrated was sealed when he threw that TD pick to Porter.

 

[MAKAVELI25]

True story. Every SB game the D has let the opposing team come back and tied it. Brady has had to comeback and lead his team to a game winning score for the 3 SBs they won.

On the SB loses, Brady has led his team to TD drives within 3 minutes of both games only for the D to blow it.
The SB loss Peyton orchestrated was sealed when he threw that TD pick to Porter.

fukk you AND your sig, bytch nikka

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

True story. Every SB game the D has let the opposing team come back and tied it. Brady has had to comeback and lead his team to a game winning score for the 3 SBs they won.

On the SB loses, Brady has led his team to TD drives within 3 minutes of both games only for the D to blow it.
The SB loss Peyton orchestrated was sealed when he threw that TD pick to Porter.

You must have missed the stat posted earlier that Peyton has a lost game in the playoffs his team has had the lead in the last 40 seconds of 6 times. There's a big difference between driving where you have to score a touchdown and driving where you only have to get into field goal range, Brady now knows this difference well. Also in the 2007 SB he got the ball back last and proceeded to overthrow Randy Moss twice when he broke away from the d

You can blame Peyton for Reggie Wayne running the wrong route all day but I'd rather have a QB who takes those shots versus one who was conditioned to not even know how. That's what happens when you were forced to carry a team for years you have to step out the dink and dunk comfort zone

 

[Lakers Offseason]

You must have missed the stat posted earlier that Peyton has a lost game in the playoffs his team has had the lead in the last 40 seconds of 6 times. There's a big difference between driving where you have to score a touchdown and driving where you only have to get into field goal range, Brady now knows this difference well. Also in the 2007 SB he got the ball back last and proceeded to overthrow Randy Moss twice when he broke away from the d

You can blame Peyton for Reggie Wayne running the wrong route all day but I'd rather have a QB who takes those shots versus one who was conditioned to not even know how. That's what happens when you were forced to carry a team for years you have to step out the dink and dunk comfort zone

The best way to compare them is to put them in similar situations and how it plays out. In one of their SBs they both got the ball late in the fourth with less than 10 minutes to go and the game up for grabs.

Here's what they did:

Brady drove his team down for a TD to take the lead. His mistake was leaving 2 minutes and change on the clock for Tyree's helmet.

Peyton, on his chance, threw a TD pass to seal the game. His mistake was he threw it to an opposing team member

See the difference?

 

[Jesus Shuttlesworth]

True story. Every SB game the D has let the opposing team come back and tied it. Brady has had to comeback and lead his team to a game winning score for the 3 SBs they won.

On the SB loses, Brady has led his team to TD drives within 3 minutes of both games only for the D to blow it.
The SB loss Peyton orchestrated was sealed when he threw that TD pick to Porter.

Football is 60 minutes, not 10 seconds. Those Rams score 35+ on any other team and Brady has no chance to throw screens down the field, setting up clutch FG's.

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

The best way to compare them is to put them in similar situations and how it plays out. In one of their SBs they both got the ball late in the fourth with less than 10 minutes to go and the game up for grabs.

Here's what they did:

Brady drove his team down for a TD to take the lead. His mistake was leaving 2 minutes and change on the clock for Tyree's helmet.

Peyton, on his chance, threw a TD pass to seal the game. His mistake was he threw it to an opposing team member

See the difference?

If you're gonna use "similar situations" use them from the same game both played in where the context is much similiar

2006 AFCG game. Both had the ball with a chance to get their team the lead in the last 3 minutes

Peyton drove his team down the field for a game winning TD, Brady got the ball back last and threw a game ending interception

See the difference?

 

[Lakers Offseason]

If you're gonna use "similar situations" use them from the same game both played in where the context is much similiar

2006 AFCG game. Both had the ball with a chance to get their team the lead in the last 3 minutes

Peyton drove his team down the field for a game winning TD, Brady got the ball back last and threw a game ending interception

See the difference?

Awful example.

My example at least both teams they were working with had similar in talents offensively.

The example you provided, Manning had his sick offensive players, Brady was working with Reche Caldwell and Gaffney as his WRs


Of course you're gonna go back to this game though. It's the only game where Peyton actually was clutch

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

Awful example.

My example at least both teams they were working with had similar in talents offensively.

The example you provided, Manning had his sick offensive players, Brady was working with Reche Caldwell and Gaffney as his WRs


Of course you're gonna go back to this game though. It's the only game where Peyton actually was clutch

You took two out of context examples from different years, different teams, complete different situations. That was actually a horrible example.

I fixed it for you and gave you an example of the two players we're comparing, in the same game, put into the same situation in the last few minutes of the game

You just didn't like the result so now you're backpedaling, like people with your stance often do

Why does Brady receivers matter now when the defense he was wielding when he won those titles 10 years ago don't?

 

[ill]

Who would you rely on more to get you to the Superbowl every year? Brady or Peyton?

Thats the end game, right? If you say Peyton you are biased and WRONG. Sorry bruhs but its the truth. #NumbersDontLie


Edit: Also - Who would you rely on more in the playoffs? The guy with 7 first round exits? Really????

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

Who would you rely on more to get you to the Superbowl every year? Brady or Peyton?

Thats the end game, right? If you say Peyton you are biased and WRONG. Sorry bruhs but its the truth. #NumbersDontLie

The endgame is not getting to the superbowl. Even Rex Grossman got to one. The end game is winning the ring, which Brady hasn't done in 10 years

Now if you're arguing who would you rely on to lose a superbowl in spectacular fashion.....

 

[ill]

The endgame is not getting to the superbowl. Even Rex Grossman got to one. The end game is winning the ring, which Brady hasn't done in 10 years

Now if you're arguing who would you rely on to lose a superbowl in spectacular fashion.....

I'll take the guy that can AT LEAST make the SB than the guy with 7 first round exits. Cmon now you can't be serious.

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

I'll take the guy that can AT LEAST make the SB than the guy with 7 first round exits. Cmon now you can't be serious.

10 years

Peytons made it to the same amount and won more since Brady lost Adam V and his hall of fame D

 

[Bboystyle]

10 years

last SB winning season for Brady, 2004.

Last SB winning season for Manning 2006


Seriously breh, whats your fukking point here? 2 years difference and yet u bashing brady for it and not Peyton.

 

[ill]

10 years

Peytons made it to the same amount and won more since Brady lost Adam V and his hall of fame D

But the facts remain that Brady has 3 and Peyton has 1

And Peyton hasn't won in 7 years.........