Peyton Manning STILL has a better playoff passer rating than Tom Brady

Street Knowledge

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
27,990
Reputation
2,793
Daps
67,557
Reppin
NYC
Brady playoffs
Per game: 23-37, 248 yards, 1.8 TD, 0.9 INT

Manning Playoffs
Per game: 24-38, 284 yards, 1.6 TD, 1.1 INT

Higher TD percentage/Lower Interception Percentage Near identical accuracy=Better PS QB
 

cook

Banned
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Reputation
11,266
Daps
48,012
Hopefully I don't have to explain to you why a balanced team benefits you more in the playoffs than the regular season

No, but maybe you could explain to me why brady is the all time playoff wins leader while peyton has a sub .500 win percentage. And when you explain that please make sure you cover the fact that bradys playoff oppenents have a higher regular season winning percentage than manning's
 

Snitchin Splatter

Working With The Feds
Joined
Dec 18, 2012
Messages
8,273
Reputation
1,959
Daps
14,804
Reppin
Confidential Informants
No, but maybe you could explain to me why brady is the all time playoff wins leader while peyton has a sub .500 win percentage. And when you explain that please make sure you cover the fact that bradys playoff oppenents have a higher regular season winning percentage than manning's

"Brady all time leader in wins" because he was the only person playing in all of those wins and most of them didn't come when he was a scrub playing with the best kicker and one of the best defenses of all time. :usure:
 

cook

Banned
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Reputation
11,266
Daps
48,012
"Brady all time leader in wins" because he was the only person playing in all of those wins and most of them didn't come when he was a scrub playing with the best kicker and one of the best defenses of all time. :usure:

How many years did the best kicker of all time play with brady. And how many years did he play with manning?
 

Snitchin Splatter

Working With The Feds
Joined
Dec 18, 2012
Messages
8,273
Reputation
1,959
Daps
14,804
Reppin
Confidential Informants
How many years did the best kicker of all time play with brady. And how many years did he play with manning?

He played with Brady throughout ALL of his superbowl runs and had an instrumental poisiton in each, where they won each one by 3 points, 2 of them soley off his game winning kicks, and the other off a kick in the snow that propelled them to the title.

When Peyton won his while marching through Brady he didn't have to depend on a kick to do it as they beat the best defense in the league by double digits

But lets go back to you giving brady all of the credit for those playoff wins you think he won on his own, how much credit does he get for the 10 years after of failures and historic choke jobs to underdogs :lupe: Let me guess now it's on other players
 

JLova

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
60,022
Reputation
4,659
Daps
182,392
Folk don't even remember Vanderjagt shanking kicks in the playoffs?

Vanderjagt was missing them while Vinateri was making them.
Guess that was Peyton's fault too. :heh:
 

cook

Banned
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Reputation
11,266
Daps
48,012
Im sorry im having trouble here, you answered a simple question with a novel. I'm having trouble understanding why brady was able to win 3 chips because of the goat kicker yet manning was only able to win 1. could you break that great point down since you brought it up
 

Born2BKing

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
87,019
Reputation
16,420
Daps
347,496
Say what yall want but both Peyton and Brady only won Super Bowls because they had a all-star defense. The year Peyton won the SB, the defense carried him in the playoffs with his poor play. And Brady only won win he had a ALLSTAR DEFENSE from top to bottom. The only person to win without a defense is Drew
Naw but ask these dudes, Tom Brady was the anchor behind those 3 super bowl rings. They fail to mention his stats during those 3 playoff runs.
 
Top