Looks like Rodgers never throws picks in those situations while Manning does, but Manning wins like 30% of those games. The basic premise is that Rodgers and McCarthy are too risk averse in situations that favor the bold.
no, thats a logical fallacy. there are no 'situations that favor the bold' stemming from this stat
you clowns gobble that stat up not even thinking... the stat is close to useless
simple situation: bears are up 23-7 late in the game. jay cutler goes and throws two pick sixes. game is now 23-21. bears win the game on a defensive stand.
this stat says jay cutler's such 'record' is 1-0 after this game. who the fukking hell cares ?
this stat tells you absolutely nothing about being in a shootout or any other garbage thing
moreover, it does not account for qbs stats when their team was leading, to team losing the lead because of their actions. it never accounts for qbs actions at all. it also doesnt account for some qbs offenses mounting a large comeback and still falling short. like I've said, it's a meaningless stat more or less.
oh and manning doesn't 'win' games. his team wins games. just like with any qb