Question For Smart People Only

Archangel

Banned
Joined
May 10, 2015
Messages
8,992
Reputation
2,791
Daps
39,654
With this analogy, you're conflating genetics with cultural identity. The two can be correlated, but aren't exactly the same thing.

The dialog I'm trying to start is this:

Does our ancestry determine our identity or does our place of birth? Obviously I am of African ancestry but have never even been on the continent. I was born in America. That makes me an African American right.

But let's say I moved to Japan and had a child. Would that child be then considered an African American Asian?
 

Deuterion

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 2, 2018
Messages
6,577
Reputation
3,633
Daps
41,454
Reppin
LBC
The dialog I'm trying to start is this:

Does our ancestry determine our identity or does our place of birth? Obviously I am of African ancestry but have never even been on the continent. I was born in America. That makes me an African American right.

But let's say I moved to Japan and had a child. Would that child be then considered an African American Asian?

To the point in red, it's not either/or...both your ancestry and your place of birth determine your identity. Your place of birth is the ecology in which you are reared and your ancestry is the foundation on which you stand. If we look at the term "African-American" you can see that the African denotes our heritage and the American let's you know that we are in the USA. So if you want to understand our history and our current position you would need to research how African people were treated in the USA.

To the point in blue, if you had a child in Japan with an African-American your child would be Afro-Japanese (if Japan granted the child citizenship which they probably wouldn't).
 

invalid

Veteran
Joined
Feb 21, 2015
Messages
20,340
Reputation
7,085
Daps
82,224
The dialog I'm trying to start is this:

Does our ancestry determine our identity or does our place of birth? Obviously I am of African ancestry but have never even been on the continent. I was born in America. That makes me an African American right.

But let's say I moved to Japan and had a child. Would that child be then considered an African American Asian?

This question posits on the assumption that black Americans retained their original African genetic profile. They didn’t. Majority are a hybrid of African, European, and Indigenous bloodlines. So no, an African elephant that has moved to America + has been breeded with other elephant breeds is no longer a pure bread African elephant.

A black person that moves to Japan and has a child, that child would be Afro-Japanese.
 

King Khufu

CARTEL MAFIA GANG
Joined
Jan 1, 2018
Messages
5,210
Reputation
-571
Daps
8,832
Reppin
At Ur Mama's Bando
The only real difference is Environmental dietary may affect genetics. Notice how the Asia Elephant is only slightly smaller than African Elephants yet they are both equally strong and can serve well in it's terrains.

Many Asian elephants were used as vehicles in early years as they were easily trainable to marsh in highland swamps, where African elephants congregate in family herds more in open grassland fields so were revered as a sacred animal for it's honorable family system (which lead to minimal domestication.)

Sorry if I didn't sound scientific I am in a bad mood but the question was well worth answering! Hope you got what you sought!
 

King Khufu

CARTEL MAFIA GANG
Joined
Jan 1, 2018
Messages
5,210
Reputation
-571
Daps
8,832
Reppin
At Ur Mama's Bando
Geography is a social construct

In what way you saying this?
You saying that land names are just place markers for people, or are you saying that land areas being separated by body of waters is illusion?

You know, some people believe the Earth is actually still a Pangaea.
 

SAINT

All $ IN
Supporter
Joined
Mar 18, 2015
Messages
19,784
Reputation
6,145
Daps
108,109
Depends. The real question you should be asking is if that elephant is eligible for reparations :jbhmm:
 
Top