Morning sis,
For me it boils down to consistency, longevity, skills and overall body of work. A few years back, it was brought to my attention that R Kelly wrote for Michael Jackson. I was floored!
He’s got a deeper discography that has transcended time. He’s innovative, the singing hip hop style really took on new levels between Teddy Riley and R Kelly’s execution of the song structure. A structure that was really non existent in the 60s, 70s, and 80s.
He’s not a better singer than D, nor is he as conscious but he has the ability to make records that connect with everyone. Obviously he can make the standard R&B records for women but he can also give you better niche records; for instance, You have sad ballads that touch on mourning loved ones who are no longer with us “I Wish”, or the inspiring “I believe I can fly” or “Worlds greatest”.
Don’t get me started on his church records or his Chicago swing records from Choclate Factory/Happy People era.........
It’s not a fair comparison. R Kelly May be the goat. He also gives a great live show.
I love D, but he’s not as versatile as Kells. He also lacks the consistency and depth in his body of work to be compared to him
Just my .2