Race, Morgan & The Walking Dead - A Coli Article

DPresidential

The Coli's Ralph Ellison
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
24,507
Reputation
12,981
Daps
99,317
Reppin
Old Brooklyn
Race, Morgan & The Walking Dead - A Coli Article

This article asks readers to only sit down with common sense and a desire for honest discussion and focused debate. Enjoy.
amc-s-fear-the-walking-dead-is-a-poor-representation-for-black-people-598717.jpg



The main crux of the The Walking Dead TV show can be viewed in two ways. One, in which we enjoy the roller coaster of people trying to stay alive and avoid getting bit by cute scary zombies. The second, we, as an audience, look to see how long any semblance of humanity exists in the godforsaken people that are still alive in the hell that is the Walking Dead universe. I surmise that the latter is the true story here.

Let's be clear, if we want to go down the path of claiming that there are racist vibes...we have to go all the way down that rabbit hole with our common sense. However, before we touch on that, let's talk about hate that Morgan is getting.

morgan-jones-533x300.jpg

Here is not here. But hate is definitely hate.

At the end of the day, for Morgan & hopefully all of us, we'd hope that once we've carved out a code of ethics or morals, we will stick to them regardless of the ramifications as long as we think it's right. Many of us are expressing intense frustration and anger regarding Morgan's decisions and actions. However, we must acknowledge that Morgan has a code that he's living by, a code that has essentially saved him from insanity and we'd all agree that having a code is the most important thing is this world...with surviving being a close second.

No? Ask yourself...

If the Wolves had taken over your encampment & they've made an ultimatum stating that the only way to survive the pillaging is to become a sex slave & dress up as concubines that get shared amongst the wolves... How many of yall would rather die that survive like that?

If you'd rather die, it's because of your code of conduct and dressing up as females for the pleasure of the Wolves just to stay alive...would be outside of your parameters of survival because it would be against what you believe makes you...you.

main-qimg-b17d5218add8a303816ef57f7b46a604

"W is for Whispering sweet nothings in your ear"

If you are of the school of thought that you'd do anything to survive...then, and only then do I understand your frustration with Morgan. However, if you are of the school of thought that believes that having a code of conduct, ethics & morals to keep you sane & keep you from devolving into the savagery of "the wolves", you really shouldn't be hating Morgan even if you disagree with his code. At the end of the day, Morgan believes his sanity means more than Rick's baby's safety. I actually respect that.

kBdDRfC.png

What is right and wrong? Right, in this world, is whatever helps me sleep at night. fukk the safety of anyone else.

Now the elephant in the room with the Ku Klux Klan hood on…

Let’s discuss the apparent racist under/overtones that exist in the story direction & character actions of the Walking Dead Universe. I definitely felt extremely uncomfortable with showing Morgan in a cage on the plantation of a white guy teaching a black man “how to be civilized.” That definitely got the gears running in my mind however, if we are going to go down that path, again, we need to do it intelligently and unbiased.

The first episode needs to be talked about with respect to the themes of race that play or don’t play with respect to the Walking Dead universe.

Remember that first episode with Merle, Daryl’s racist brother?
walking-dead-s1e2-guts-06.jpg

"I don't give a fukk if it took zombies to get rid of institutional racism. I'M STANDING MY GROUND. Murica."


There is an argument that race politics, atleast within the realm of the Walking Dead universe, is a device that has become near extinct as a result of necessity and survival. Merle’s statements to T-Dog indicate somewhat of the last remaining human culture codes that humanity, in its civility [ironic], created as a result of intellectual superiority complex. In a world such as the apocalypse, when your next meal may be an expired can of Brussel sprouts and you haven’t changed a pair of your underwear for 5 months, racial bias may not survive too long.

Now…it could. I could definitely see an apocalypse situation that occurs where limited resource management becomes divided by cultural lines however, the creators created a trajectory where it starts to become non-existent as a result of necessity. It’s their world, we’re just watching it.

With respect to the story trajectory inside of the AMC studios boardroom, there is an argument that can be had that as a result of intense character development of key black characters such as Morgan, Michonne and others, the characters story arcs are being created with a colorblind focus. Any person could be Michonne, any person could be Rick and any person could be Glenn. The characters are not drawn up with respect to racial stereotypes.

Let’s get a little deeper though…because all of that still doesn’t touch on Morgan being in a cage in a white man’s house.
amc_twd_s6a_604_makingof_heresnothere-800x450.jpg

"Okay, now show a little more white privilege. And ACTION"

Interestingly, Eastmann worked for a Department of Corrections as a psychologist in the Walking Dead universe. A few things should be paid attention to.

One, Eastmann never locked the gate, Morgan was never really enslaved. Two, Eastmann was plagued by the same savagery that Morgan was and guess what? The white guy was a savage in the world before the end of the world. In a way, a parallel can be made arguing that many of the problems facing Black people in this Country are a result of intense oppressive situations & circumstance…what are white people’s excuse for the same savagery? That alone counter’s the argument that the Walking Dead is racist because a white man quells the savagery of a black man. And lastly, Eastmann indicates to Morgan that almost everyone, outside of one person, is not evil or bad and the reason why they are making such bad and heinous decisions is because of an oppressive society and the demands that said society places on people. Think about that in contrast to the prevailing view of how society wrongly believes there is a black and white line of what or who is good and who is bad.
 
Last edited:

Jello Biafra

A true friend stabs you in the front
Supporter
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
46,165
Reputation
4,900
Daps
120,762
Reppin
Behind You
I appreciate the thought you put into this but nothing you wrote gets to the heart of my frustration with what TWD has done to Morgan (and also what has happened with every black male character on this show) and that is that for some reason the decision is made that no black man on TWD can be an Alpha Male. They all have to have something in their character make-up that completely removes them from the level of a Rick or Daryl and presents them to the audience as weak.
I don't know if it is intentional or subconscious but it is there.
 

DPresidential

The Coli's Ralph Ellison
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
24,507
Reputation
12,981
Daps
99,317
Reppin
Old Brooklyn
I appreciate the thought you put into this but nothing you wrote gets to the heart of my frustration with what TWD has done to Morgan (and also what has happened with every black male character on this show) and that is that for some reason the decision is made that no black man on TWD can be an Alpha Male. They all have to have something in their character make-up that completely removes them from the level of a Rick or Daryl and presents them to the audience as weak.
I don't know if it is intentional or subconscious but it is there.
Interesting.

I do admit that many of the black male characters have had characteristics of beta male mentality. However, when you look at the total amount of characters, black or white, who have had full alpha male personas...

Rick

Shane

Governor

Abraham

tt's far and between. Most of them teetering on becoming bad. My intention is not to cape for the show, which now I feel like I'm doing but let's discuss...

What makes Morgan a beta?
 

DPresidential

The Coli's Ralph Ellison
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
24,507
Reputation
12,981
Daps
99,317
Reppin
Old Brooklyn

STAN JONES

Fire John Harbaugh
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
28,532
Reputation
5,407
Daps
61,738
Reppin
Baltimore
I definitely felt extremely uncomfortable with showing Morgan in a cage on the plantation of a white guy teaching a black man “how to be civilized.”
are you fukking serious :dwillhuh:

So glad I stopped watching early in season 3
 

STAN JONES

Fire John Harbaugh
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
28,532
Reputation
5,407
Daps
61,738
Reppin
Baltimore
With respect to the story trajectory inside of the AMC studios boardroom, there is an argument that can be had that as a result of intense character development of key black characters such as Morgan, Michonne and others, the characters story arcs are being created with a colorblind focus.
negged :rudy:
 

Pinyapplesuckas

He's A Good Man
Joined
Jun 29, 2012
Messages
37,148
Reputation
10,725
Daps
95,892
Reppin
Willacoochee, Ga
are you fukking serious :dwillhuh:

So glad I stopped watching early in season 3
Morgan walked onto dudes property and shot at him. the guy knocked him out and put him in an unlocked cage. i dont think its as cut & dry as he "tried to civilize him"...i feel like this easily could have happened to Rick, Shane, or anyone else that has flown off the cuffs..

it DOES look a little sus tho...i just dont think it can be so easily boiled down to "teaching a black man to be civilized" because we can go back to the beginning episodes and we all know Morgan is more than civilized..he's just going thru that rough patch of PTSD everyone seems to go thru and needs to be brought back to reality.
 

O.T.I.S.

Veteran
Joined
Sep 15, 2013
Messages
69,885
Reputation
14,737
Daps
270,171
Reppin
The Truth
Morgan is a badass and pretty much is an alpha (or Omega at least) male. You can tell by how he kills Walkers or even others people in the past... He was the one that taught Rick how to survive and was living out there alone when he went crazy... It would've happened to anyone who lasted that long alone...

Rick is going crazy, Michonne was going crazy until she got a friend, the pastor was going crazy, etc.

Morgan had just went off the deep end already, and it took some hippie Aikdo, Bo staff using pychiatrist to help begin his path from his ptsd.. Which was basically all the killing/dying around him

I looked at this episode as nothing more than that. Now Morgan is trying to use the same technique against the Wolves because not only did it work for him, but he needs to in order not to go back to "Clearer" Morgan.. Which was basically what the Wolves are

But it won't work because the wolves don't want to come back and Morgan is no expert psychiatrist
 

DPresidential

The Coli's Ralph Ellison
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
24,507
Reputation
12,981
Daps
99,317
Reppin
Old Brooklyn
Morgan walked onto dudes property and shot at him. the guy knocked him out and put him in an unlocked cage. i dont think its as cut & dry as he "tried to civilize him"...i feel like this easily could have happened to Rick, Shane, or anyone else that has flown off the cuffs..

it DOES look a little sus tho...i just dont think it can be so easily boiled down to "teaching a black man to be civilized" because we can go back to the beginning episodes and we all know Morgan is more than civilized..he's just going thru that rough patch of PTSD everyone seems to go thru and needs to be brought back to reality.
This. That's exactly how I felt.

@STAN JONES That's the first time I've ever been negged. :lupe: What's the problem breh? How about you discuss, that's the point of a forum.




Morgan is a badass and pretty much is an alpha (or Omega at least) male. You can tell by how he kills Walkers or even others people in the past... He was the one that taught Rick how to survive and was living out there alone when he went crazy... It would've happened to anyone who lasted that long alone...

Rick is going crazy, Michonne was going crazy until she got a friend, the pastor was going crazy, etc.

Morgan had just went off the deep end already, and it took some hippie Aikdo, Bo staff using pychiatrist to help begin his path from his ptsd.. Which was basically all the killing/dying around him

I looked at this episode as nothing more than that. Now Morgan is trying to use the same technique against the Wolves because not only did it work for him, but he needs to in order not to go back to "Clearer" Morgan.. Which was basically what the Wolves are

But it won't work because the wolves don't want to come back and Morgan is no expert psychiatrist

I absolutely agree with you. He needs to find a balance between the two in order for him to live in this world if he is going to care about anybody else. The problem is, he does care about everyone else, but his philosophy puts them in danger.
 

TheGreatShowtime

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
49,884
Reputation
11,998
Daps
233,304
Reppin
The Swamp
Can we just wait and see how the Morgan character will play out? For fukks sake, he's only been on three episodes this season. The last episode showed incredible character growth from him. I agree that the Walking Dead has a bad track record for minority characters, but all I'm saying is wait and see how Morgan plays out.

I've said this in the season thread, but there's a huge lack of Asian/Indian/Middle Eastern presence on both shows. Yet these groups make up a significant portion of the population in the south. Hell, there's not even that much Latino presence on the main show. They spun off that other wack ass show to appease the Latino fanbase. Glenn is the only Asian character on the show, and I don't ever recall them running into any other Asian characters.
 
Last edited:

STAN JONES

Fire John Harbaugh
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
28,532
Reputation
5,407
Daps
61,738
Reppin
Baltimore
This. That's exactly how I felt.

@STAN JONES That's the first time I've ever been negged. :lupe: What's the problem breh? How about you discuss, that's the point of a forum.






I absolutely agree with you. He needs to find a balance between the two in order for him to live in this world if he is going to care about anybody else. The problem is, he does care about everyone else, but his philosophy puts them in danger.
Its all propaganda breh

Please dont ever be that naive to believe that ANY show or movie is made with a colorblind focus

They know EXACTLY what they're doing
 
Top