Ranked them 1-3 based on their careers in their prime? Maddux, Johnson, Pedro

[Jeffrey Lebowski]

Can't forget about Steve Avery and Mark Wohlers at closer. I wasn't even 10 and I remember that whole team.

Denny Neagle was no slouch either

 

[ryderldb]

At their absolute prime

1. Pedro
2. johnson
3. Maddux

No wrong answer though imo