I agree with them on Sergio against Murray (came back too soon after the JCC Jr fight and delivered just a piss poor performance overall), Alvarez against Floyd (his basically just giving up and accepting that he was going to lose the decision to Floyd was terrible), Donaire against Rigondeaux (pretty much resigned himself to losing at a certain point in the fight like what happened to Alvarez against Mayweather plus Nonito acted like a ho after the fight with all of his excuses) and JCC Jr against Vera (Jr is just lazy and tends to train/perform down to the level of his comp).
I've noticed that when athletes comeback from knee surgeries that 1st outing back (if they a fighter) is usually subpar (in other sports depending on what they needed fix, I've seen it take anythnig from 6-12 months to fully recover), even more so when said athlete is in their 30's. So I wasnt that surprised Sergio was horrid vs Murray, but also Murray doesnt really give you anythnig with his style so it made the Sergio look even worse.
Donaire just doesnt look good at the weight and the fact that he fell in love with his power doesnt help either. If anything, barring the last round of the fight his performance vs Darchinyan was alot worse.
Saul Gingerman had no chance vs Floyd, the hype outweighted his actual chances in the fight. His stamina is still questionable, the only thing he had goin for him was his youth and a bit of speed but its nothnig that Floyd hasnt seen before. Floyd just makes good/talented fighters look ordinary
Broner vs Paulie doesnt deserve to be up there IMO.