RDR or GTA4?

[TheGregReaper]

Red Dead is one of the best experiences I've had from this gen.

 

[Tom]

I know. Thats where I'm at in UDN

well i guess im assed out then


ain't shyt else for me to do

and nah i haven't made it to mexico yet, the bridges ain't even up

 

[3Rivers]

Red Dead

but Ballad of Gay Tony should have just been GTAIV and they shoulda threw Niko in the Bushes

John Marston
Luis Lopez
Johnny Klebbitz

>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Niko Bellic

I couldn't get into the character at all. Maybe I'll try to play through it again

 

[Heretic]

well i guess im assed out then


ain't shyt else for me to do

and nah i haven't made it to mexico yet, the bridges ain't even up

There's more shyt 2 do, I just 4got what. But certain missions are only available at certain times. And there's 4 horses to get but you dont actually hafta get them to finish the game. I put about 12hrs in that game but I was bs'n a lot and there is a definite ending to the game you'll know if you beat it.

 

[Tom]

 

[havoc00]

RDR was prob my favorite game this generation, but that Undead Nightmare to me was pretty boring honestly.

 

[WHolla09]

RDR was great all the way through. GTA got a little boring at parts.

 

[Bboystyle]

RDR and it aint even close...Soon as i popped in GTA4 and tried to shoot people then drive i turned that shyt off and made a coaster out of it...Worse fukking GTA ever made...

 

[dabestkeptsecret]

Red Dead

but Ballad of Gay Tony should have just been GTAIV and they shoulda threw Niko in the Bushes

tbogt was the perfect experience. Crazy off the wall missions; great main character that was interesting; and good story and length. The niko story went on forever, and after that bank robbery i stopped caring.

 

[duncanthetall]

They need to come out with a sequel to RDR. That ending had me

 

[drugxglory]

GTA 4.
A friend let me borrow RDR but i didnt really like it, fukk riding a damn horse across the map.. I like the city feel, hoping in expensive cars, buying clothes, all that shyt so, gta.

 

[marcuz]

GTA 4.
A friend let me borrow RDR but i didnt really like it, fukk riding a damn horse across the map.. I like the city feel, hoping in expensive cars, buying clothes, all that shyt so, gta.

i had more fun riding horses


who cares how expensive a car is, i'm going to just crash that shyt anyways.

 

[Ralph Wiggum]

GTA 4.
A friend let me borrow RDR but i didnt really like it, fukk riding a damn horse across the map.. I like the city feel, hoping in expensive cars, buying clothes, all that shyt so, gta.

but i thought you liked gta IV??

 

[Rack4K]

Never finished Red Dead, this thread has me feeling like mistakes were made






-P-

Sorry breh, but if you didn't experience the ending....

Crazy

RDR > GTA4...no question. The games have a lot of the same framework but what puts RDR over GTA4 is the historical setting, art direction, score and story.

 

[Tryna Makit]

And now I knowwwww this compass is all I neeeed. Had me like "I'm comin darlin"