RDR or GTA4?

[Wiirdo]

Which did you prefer, think was better and why?

 

[Heretic]

I think rdr was so much better, it had atmosphere, the story was great. Most importantly, doing missions never felt like a chore to me.

 

[Marci-Senpai]

RDR of course...bestt game of this generation.....

 

[DosCadenaz]

Red Dead Redemption was to me

 

[DetroitEWarren]

Just started playing RDR and that shyt is out cold, I had no idea it was so fun. The graphics shyt on GTA also, it has some of the best graphics on 360 imo. I love that game, but I cant say I would prefer it over GTA 4, msybe the same level, but not better to me.

 

[BrothaZay]

I havent played RDR. I tried looking up the map and seeing how it was like.

Do you go from town to town bacc in the wild west days and the little towns actually have that wild west atmosphere?

 

[Why-Fi]

its completely wild west atmosphere. first reply nailed it

i love best about this game the side quest system incorporated into the environment. you out doing your open world thing and randomly witness a robbery...npcs screaming at you like HAAAALP. plus the gunplay is great. RDR destroys gta 4 on so many levels

if its any indication of their future games gta 5 is on course to murder everything standing

 

[rocksteady]

I havent played RDR. I tried looking up the map and seeing how it was like.

Do you go from town to town bacc in the wild west days and the little towns actually have that wild west atmosphere?

yes, everything has the wild west atmosphere.

from the story, setting, characters, music, dialogue to the costumes and weapons - all of this in addition to the great gameplay combined, makes for an excellent gaming experience.

let's just say, there are a lot of different things you can do in different ways (don't want to give spoilers).

 

[Why-Fi]

yes the characters. west nigel dikkens is one of my fav game characters of all time

 

[Liquid]

RDR easy for me

 

[Kodie]

RDR for me. No question.

 

[Roid Jones]

Gonna have to say RDR

 

[teacher]

can I ask for a vowel?

 

[3Rivers]

Red Dead>>>>>>>>>>>>>

-Atmosphere
-Crossing over into Mexico
-Actually giving a fukk about the main character
-Hunting animals
-Hog tying random people,then dropping them off in the middle of the wild west and putting a bullet in their head
-Riding out into the dark snowy forrest and having to be on the look out for bear's/cougars

Red Dead was that shyt

 

[The G.O.D II]

Both great games but if you have to make one choice its RDR. Great atmosphere (the song they play when you first get to mexico ), great cohesive story with one of the best endings ever in a game, tons of shyt to do. It shyts all over GTA4 now that I think about it