Is Trent Dilfer a HOFer??
Richard Sherman on Matthew Stafford’s HOF case
- Thread starter Street Knowledge
- Start date
get these nets
Veteran
Real
Location: Under Your Skin
Well, neither is Richard Sherman
mastermind
Rest In Power Kobe
Sherman has a better case than Stafford and probably will make it.Well, neither is Richard Sherman
He played in Detroit tho, don’t act like he was playing with all pro talent.. Only cat he really had was Megatron
Real
Location: Under Your Skin
True
vs the bears and Minnesota, multiple times a year for a ~decade…foh with this shyt, he wasn’t playing all pro competition either.
Meanwhile rodgers absolutely thrived and dominated vs the same comp easily.
Renegade47
Superstar
sherman a lockWell, neither is Richard Sherman
Real
Location: Under Your Skin
Definitely not a lock imo
Not to mention, he played 6 seasons with Megatron, 4 of them were with Jim Schwartz as HC (he never sniffed another head coaching job) and then Megatron retired after 2 seasons with Jim Caldwell. The Lions still made the playoffs twice and had a winning record under Caldwell. Then the fired him and hired Matt Patricia for 3 seasons. That's the entirety of Stafford's time with the lions.
Going back 20 years, there are probably 4 HOF quarterbacks.
Brady, Peyton, Rodgers, and Brees.
(Favre, too. Though I'd consider him more of a 90s QB)
That's it. But I'm more conservative when it comes to HOF than most.
If you want to argue for Roethlisberger, fine. But the guy won 2 super bowls early in his career and did nothing for the last decade of it. He wasn't ever a transcendent QB. But fine. It's not a hill I'm willing to die on.
Matt Stafford has a career 86-95-1 record. He's won a championship, sure. But he doesn't stand out in a way that the HOF needs to include him to tell story of the NFL during the past decade. Nothing is lost if he isn't memorialized.
Brady, Peyton, Rodgers, and Brees.
(Favre, too. Though I'd consider him more of a 90s QB)
That's it. But I'm more conservative when it comes to HOF than most.
If you want to argue for Roethlisberger, fine. But the guy won 2 super bowls early in his career and did nothing for the last decade of it. He wasn't ever a transcendent QB. But fine. It's not a hill I'm willing to die on.
Matt Stafford has a career 86-95-1 record. He's won a championship, sure. But he doesn't stand out in a way that the HOF needs to include him to tell story of the NFL during the past decade. Nothing is lost if he isn't memorialized.
Renegade47
Superstar
he was the best cb for a stretch on one of the best defensive teams ever. all decade team 5 time all pro 5 pro bowl and he won a SB. he’s a lock. wont take him long to get in either
HoF players elevate rosters…this dude never elevated any team, not even the rams any of the top ~15 qbs would’ve won with this team.
You dudes hopping on a bandwagon and did not watch stafford play, I watched him and like I stated before…no one ever looked at any team Matthew stafford was on and thought “damn Matt is about to kill us
“ never once.Even in the sb he was far from the best performance on the team.
People making these arguments couldn’t have watched him play. Good qbs on bad teams still show out, he actively lost Detroit hella games so cut blaming the talent. Most of his stats came from light defenses in garbage time with him trying to come back because they were out of the game 90% of the time, with most of that due to his inconsistent play….
HoF players elevate rosters…this dude never elevated any team, not even the rams any of the top ~15 qbs would’ve won with this team.
You dudes hopping on a bandwagon and did not watch stafford play, I watched him and like I stated before…no one ever looked at any team Matthew stafford was on and thought “damn Matt is about to kill us
Even in the sb he was far from the best performance on the team.
People making these arguments couldn’t have watched him play. Good qbs on bad teams still show out, he actively lost Detroit hella games so cut blaming the talent. Most of his stats came from light defenses in garbage time with him trying to come back because they were out of the game 90% of the time, with most of that due to his inconsistent play….
This is why this forum is hilarious….
we went from bad trade, we won’t win shyt with Staff to anybody can win with this super team.
these dudes are just emotional haters. I’m loving it
