Yep they're all done for the most part
And Alex Smith and Aaron Rodgers still going strong
And Alex Smith and Aaron Rodgers still going strong
Roethlisberger-Eli Manning-Rivers... These guys are done
- Thread starter CrimsonTider
- Start date
Ineedmoney504
SOHH ICEY...WE EATIN
Brees puts up a lot of garbage time stats and tds and makes the game look close when the defense is in prevent. Getting beat by 30 wit 5 minutes left and he still throwing that bytch. And he throws a lot of pick 6's Ben has had the more impressive career imo
Time for him and Sean Payton to met they bushes
Ineedmoney504
SOHH ICEY...WE EATIN
brees ain't in that crew fam
send him to elway to finish his careerWhile getting the ball out on 1.85 sec average.
I don't think Eli is [totally] done, but it's just time he and the Giants split up, after this season. They need to do a major reset and he's too old to ride through it.
why is the bottom relevant tho. Both of them are younger. Alex ain't got many years left either. Rodgers ain't even start till like season 3 so they will prolong his career
brees ain't in that crew fam
send him to elway to finish his career
why is the bottom relevant tho. Both of them are younger. Alex ain't got many years left either. Rodgers ain't even start till like season 3 so they will prolong his career
Bottom is relevant cause they're the 2005 qb draft class 1st rounders
Ineedmoney504
SOHH ICEY...WE EATIN
One of them was in and out the game for years and the other had a goat level qb in front of him so he didn't play for years.
Ben started halfway thru his rookie year(Maddox)
Eli play halfway thru his rookie season(Kurt warner)
River(was behind brees 2 year)
So obviously they took more punishment over they career cause they played longer. The 05 class should be playing longer. Especially when none of them were full time starters until years into they careers
But whatever
Alex Smith suffered more injuries than Eli and rivers
Field Marshall Bradley
Veteran
At their peak....absolutely... Brees numbers will look better than Ben's at the end of the day though
Ineedmoney504
SOHH ICEY...WE EATIN
Idk bout Eli. Dude was just a tough ass dude who took crazy hits, same wit Ben. Rivers has a crazy quick release which helps him not get hit as much, plus he not mobile and will go down if hit unlike Ben or Eli.
At this unless wins a super bowl this year he won't ever be ranked higher than of them
Elisha did his Job and did the damn thing when eybody had them Manning Failure memes ready after he was Drafted....Im proud to have had him at QB Post Simms/Hostetler/K Collins
Is he Brady,Peyton even ARod or Breesus level?No but Ill take Elisha over ALL the QBs that came and went in the NFC bEast(minus maybe McNabb)
Is he Brady,Peyton even ARod or Breesus level?No but Ill take Elisha over ALL the QBs that came and went in the NFC bEast(minus maybe McNabb)
You discount Elis GOAT level play during those runs though . Eli has the rings and durability >>>
Make declarations after 3 weeks of football
How long we going to fall in these traps
How long we going to fall in these traps
brees ain't in that crew fam
send him to elway to finish his career
why is the bottom relevant tho. Both of them are younger. Alex ain't got many years left either. Rodgers ain't even start till like season 3 so they will prolong his career
Brees is in that crew
Brees wasn't that good in sd, and he played in a dome 80% of his career when he went to no.
Ben has 2 rings and none of them came from beating that overrated colts team, not taking anything away from breesus but it's it's debatable.
it it wasn't for a rod touching them back in the 2011 super bowl he would have had 3 rings.