Roman Reigns gets the #1 rank for Pro Wrestling Illustrated's Top 500 List

El Guapo

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
11,847
Reputation
1,674
Daps
53,452
Dean malenko (This was really suspect, im sorry, he was never ever the #1 guy on a list like this)

I remember that 97 issue. They wrote paragraphs on how it was too hard to decide :beli: so they gave it to who they thought was the best all around :beli:. They explained Hogan wasn't around much which was understandable, but in kayfabe standards Undertaker won a World title during the grading period and defended it up to SummerSlam which was more than what Dean accomplished in kayfabe. I remember being a little heated about it because I was a WWF Stan and was convinced WCW paid PWI for one of their guys to get that #1 spot :dead:
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
70,129
Reputation
14,294
Daps
97,485
Reppin
CHICAGO
Dean Malenko winning over Hogan in 97 was way worse. If its a kayfabe ranking list that is inexcusable.


I would have to fact check what the pwi ranking was then.
Plus the tone of the mag as far as the era for them as well.

Yet, for what I remember.
dean malenko was literally on fire before hogan in 97.
Regardless of how the clique and Hogan in wcw.
really just lowered him on the card via clique rules and politics.
So, if he was rated number one that would have to be true.

As malenko had freetv classics and content driven programs every week with a host of guys in a high quality wcw setting.
That was also elevating the guys in the program regardless of wins or losses.
Plus the bonus of giving guys in each program color and depth as in-ring competitors.
That far exceeded the quality of what the clique had to offer.
After the initial shock of Hogan actually turning on a consistent basis.
If an exact mid level workrate driven shift had been made to incorporate more workrate from the clique.
Or simply, found a balance between to with more from the lower high quality mid range guys.
Wcw would have had a mix at that point that would have possibly given them more wiggle room and a more natural descent of draw.
Instead clique rulez ran the place to the ground and here we are.

I really wish they would have kept malenko there and put on malenko Hogan for real for the title.
Not an after thought, who just got treated the fukk out of his spot by clique rules.
It would have made for compelling tv and would have mad Hogan do some mid level sequences that could have bolstered his longevity and relevency a bit more as well.

So if it is true,,....
The 97 pwi did give the nod to malenko.
that may have a been a good thing, for that era.
As a footnote to what was actually better in quality in reality.
Not a pr bit with false tale narratives, to rank some bullshyt other guy or thee guy, or however in the fukk.
The clique rules fukks up every sure thing draw to exit a curtain.


Art Barr
 

:-)

All Star
Supporter
Joined
Jul 24, 2015
Messages
2,952
Reputation
225
Daps
6,025
_sexy%20roman%20reigns%208_zps9jqj7wsi.gif
My smile to the wrestling smarks #RomanEmpireStrikesBack :blessed:
 
Top