Shedeur Sanders vs Caleb Williams as NFL prospects

How close are Shedeur and Caleb as prospects?


  • Total voters
    150

desjardins

Veteran
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
18,945
Reputation
1,682
Daps
70,407
Reppin
Mustard Island
Shedeur has the poise and focus of Brady and Manning. The way he handling the added pressure is crazy, that 98 yard drive may end up being the drive of the year. Caleb will be drafted higher because of the physical attributes GMs fall in love with but Shedeur will be the better NFL QB
 

vino

Retired 6/19/25…Peace
Joined
Jun 21, 2014
Messages
6,289
Reputation
676
Daps
22,313
You cannot ascertain this from playing TCU, Nebraska, and Colorado St :pachaha:

He had other seasons too. Also, TCU is not a bad team and they will end with good record, this season. Nebraska will upset a team this year as well.
 

#1 pick

The Smart Negroes
Supporter
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
79,099
Reputation
11,807
Daps
203,837
Reppin
Lamb of God
My main gripe with Caleb is his coach. He's a college qb guru and has a very qb friendly offense. Once his guys get to the league they are mediocre.
It's more so the film with Caleb. He's not a great passer in the pocket under pressure. He does most of his damage on the run or in a clean pocket like Mayfield. He's just superior talent wise to Mayfield and should easily translate to the NFL.

I think the Mahomes comps are fair when it comes to talent, in fact, Williams is more talented but Mahomes has things like leadership and will to win that I haven't seen from Williams. Also, his daddy crying about playing for a bad team is a bad look.
 
Last edited:

papa pimp

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
6,659
Reputation
817
Daps
15,405
He had other seasons too. Also, TCU is not a bad team and they will end with good record, this season. Nebraska will upset a team this year as well.

Nebraska is not good and TCU isn't bad but definitely not the team of last year. Either way, a 3 game sample for ANYONE cannot point to them having Brady/Manning level processing.
 

vino

Retired 6/19/25…Peace
Joined
Jun 21, 2014
Messages
6,289
Reputation
676
Daps
22,313
Nebraska is not good and TCU isn't bad but definitely not the team of last year. Either way, a 3 game sample for ANYONE cannot point to them having Brady/Manning level processing.

Those are extremes but his trajectory could be there as he elevates (I wasn’t the one said that). Brady has been his mentor, so that makes sense. He has more than a 3 game sample. You just don’t watch him play and you probably not really a viewer of college ball.
 

vino

Retired 6/19/25…Peace
Joined
Jun 21, 2014
Messages
6,289
Reputation
676
Daps
22,313
You referenced TCU last year as an indicator of TCU this year and said Nebraskas is good :russ: :russ: :russ:

Your reading comprehension is bad. I never referenced last year. I said TCU is a good team and will end the season with a good record. I never said Nabraska was good , I said they will upset a team. They will make a tough match up but doesn’t equate a good squad.
 
Top