should eli be benched?
- Thread starter MikelArteta
- Start date
@ this thread still being alive
@ talking about the Manningham SB catch like it was luck and not perfectly placed. Had it been Brady, Brees, Rodgers or Peyton it would've been labeled a perfect pass. 
@ the disregard for Eli's play throughout both runs to the SB. The stats say it all...since that's all y'all go by anyway. 
@ acting like Eli hasn't had solid regular seasons with over 23 game-winning drives & over 4K yards and under 20 INTs.Benching him for......Ryan Nassib? Ultra
job but nice try. This ain't Buffalo bruh.
There's no such thing as luck in the super bowl. if it happens it means you were meant to win.
Benching him for......Ryan Nassib? Ultra
tyree's catch wasn't luck that shyt was destiny. only nikkas who hate on eli should be brady cause he sonned that nikka of having 5 rings.
Ultimate Warrior
All Star
***snorts 29seconds***
Giants has played possum before they will sneak up on you, this yr damn near done, but next yr he will win it, seem like every 2 -3 yrs they go deep
Giants has played possum before they will sneak up on you, this yr damn near done, but next yr he will win it, seem like every 2 -3 yrs they go deep
I'm surprised at all the love for Eli, I think people forget how talented his offense has been plus the fact his career numbers have been very close to mediocre, dudes are talking about two Super Bowls as if he was the MAIN guy who won them, he made some plays but most guys in here would not take this guy on their team if they had the opportunity
muzikfrk75
#4080
5 INTs? 
Rocket Scientist
Superstar
As a Giant fan I gotta admit,I like Ryan Nassibs future more then Eli"s present.If he gets benched I wouldn't be worried 
JMurder
SOHH Member since 01...
He's gotta figure it out this season
another reincar prediction etched in stone
eli is finished hes matt schaub status, if his name was eli smith he'd be on the pine very shortly.
eli is finished hes matt schaub status, if his name was eli smith he'd be on the pine very shortly.
Still don't understand why that O-Line is still terrible.
New system, o line still garbage, no one could catch the ball
He deserves at least until week 6 for him and everyone else on the offense to get accustomed
He deserves at least until week 6 for him and everyone else on the offense to get accustomed
Beatty is a bum and Schwartz, who was gonna be a nice addition is on IR