Should Golden State Trade for LeBron James this Summer?

Professor Emeritus

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Supporter
Joined
Jan 5, 2015
Messages
51,331
Reputation
19,930
Daps
204,096
Reppin
the ether
Lol that's not true imo

If steph gets his 4th chip this year, not only does he tie lebron in ring count, but

  • It would be his 2nd non superteam ring without Durant
  • He would have to go through a 2nd seed Grizzlies and 1st seed 64 win Suns team on the road
  • All with Klay being "a shell of himself"
That won't be enough to put him ahead of course... but it opens the door again. What if next year, Poole and Kuminga make that leap, the team is healthy, and Curry gets out of his shooting slump? We forget that Curry is an MVP level player otherwise. It's NOT impossible that they repeat next year.

If that happens, you really don't think a discussion would be had?


This is what happens when people let Coli narratives guide their thinking instead of reality. :dead:

Duncan has a far more impressive resume than Steph does, and LeBron done passed Duncan two titles ago. It didn't matter that Duncan had 5 titles and Bron just 2, virtually everyone had LeBron ahead of Duncan and by 2016 it was literally everyone while it was still 5 titles to 3.

Let's say Steph gets two more titles and balls out in the process, picking up two Finals MVPs. Then he breaks into the Duncan discussion. In accolades Duncan would still be ahead (same MVPs, more Finals MVPs, more All-Defensive teams, more All-NBA and All-Star teams), but Steph would be legitimately in the discussion. Unfortunately Steph never carried his team to the same extent Duncan did because Steph was a weakness on the defensive side of the ball while Duncan absolutely carried his early title squads on both sides of the ball. Even on the offensive sides Steph had playoff weaknesses, no absolutely striking playoff run where he looked like an all-time GOAT. So Duncan probably still gets the nod.

And that's Duncan. He'd need binoculars to see Bron. No one is going to put Steph top-2 all-time, supplanting Bron and KAJ, just because he finally got his first or second Finals MVPs on a team good enough he could spend the first two playoff rounds coming off the bench. :heh:
 

CHICAGO

Vol. 9: Trapped
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
65,025
Reputation
13,861
Daps
412,444
Reppin
CHICAGO
Lol that's not true imo

If steph gets his 4th chip this year, not only does he tie lebron in ring count, but

  • It would be his 2nd non superteam ring without Durant
  • He would have to go through a 2nd seed Grizzlies and 1st seed 64 win Suns team on the road
  • All with Klay being "a shell of himself"
That won't be enough to put him ahead of course... but it opens the door again. What if next year, Poole and Kuminga make that leap, the team is healthy, and Curry gets out of his shooting slump? We forget that Curry is an MVP level player otherwise. It's NOT impossible that they repeat next year.

If that happens, you really don't think a discussion would be had?
:dead:YOU FORGOT TO MENTION
HE WON ALL 3 OF HIS RINGS
AGAINST LEBRON.


LeGTB IS A DELUSIONAL COMMUNITY
:devil:
:evil:
 

Black Mamba

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
17,572
Reputation
2,964
Daps
51,005
Yes do it
You know you want it GSW :mjlit:

can’t wait till we rid the lakeshow of you bron groupies go sleep on the Warriors couch:ohlawd:
 

4-Rin

Superstar
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
5,926
Reputation
2,572
Daps
23,123
Lol that's not true imo

If steph gets his 4th chip this year, not only does he tie lebron in ring count, but

  • It would be his 2nd non superteam ring without Durant
  • He would have to go through a 2nd seed Grizzlies and 1st seed 64 win Suns team on the road
  • All with Klay being "a shell of himself"
That won't be enough to put him ahead of course... but it opens the door again. What if next year, Poole and Kuminga make that leap, the team is healthy, and Curry gets out of his shooting slump? We forget that Curry is an MVP level player otherwise. It's NOT impossible that they repeat next year.

If that happens, you really don't think a discussion would be had?

Even if the warriors win this year and next year with Steph winning back to back FMVP I still don't see him surpassing Bron on the alltime list.

Bron is seen as the 2nd best after MJ, I don’t believe Curry can do anything to get that high.
 

KidJSoul

Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
19,701
Reputation
4,152
Daps
86,051
This is what happens when people let Coli narratives guide their thinking instead of reality. :dead:

Duncan has a far more impressive resume than Steph does, and LeBron done passed Duncan two titles ago. It didn't matter that Duncan had 5 titles and Bron just 2, virtually everyone had LeBron ahead of Duncan and by 2016 it was literally everyone while it was still 5 titles to 3.

Let's say Steph gets two more titles and balls out in the process, picking up two Finals MVPs. Then he breaks into the Duncan discussion. In accolades Duncan would still be ahead (same MVPs, more Finals MVPs, more All-Defensive teams, more All-NBA and All-Star teams), but Steph would be legitimately in the discussion. Unfortunately Steph never carried his team to the same extent Duncan did because Steph was a weakness on the defensive side of the ball while Duncan absolutely carried his early title squads on both sides of the ball. Even on the offensive sides Steph had playoff weaknesses, no absolutely striking playoff run where he looked like an all-time GOAT. So Duncan probably still gets the nod.

And that's Duncan. He'd need binoculars to see Bron. No one is going to put Steph top-2 all-time, supplanting Bron and KAJ, just because he finally got his first or second Finals MVPs on a team good enough he could spend the first two playoff rounds coming off the bench. :heh:
You're ignoring Duncan's flaws. He only has 3 FMVPs, and he also had some so-so finals performances (07, wtf was that? 13 he was part of the choke against the Heat)

03 is held up as this vaunted "carry job" but everyone ignores Dirk Nowitzki and Chris Webber getting hurt, and the Lakers being injured that year. Aside from that, Duncan doesn't really have any strong playoff run either. By 2013-2014, that was a full on ensemble, Duncan wasn't really head and shoulders above everyone else. He had a lot of offensive and defensive support at different stages.

Lastly, it's interesting you bring up Curry's offensive flaws, but you ignore how much he masks his own teammates defenses. He masks Draymond's inability to score/shoot, and makes Draymond look like a better passer/playmaker than he is. He also masks Klay Thompson's lack of a handle, as Klay gets free reign to get into a rhythm by chucking it or posting up against some small defender instead of being relegated to a corner 3pt shooter.
 

KidJSoul

Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
19,701
Reputation
4,152
Daps
86,051
Even if the warriors win this year and next year with Steph winning back to back FMVP I still don't see him surpassing Bron on the alltime list.

Bron is seen as the 2nd best after MJ, I don’t believe Curry can do anything to get that high.
I think there's a chance. It'll make people reevaluate history a little bit.

People are only now realizing Draymond and Klays flaws (some are saying Klay is washed, but still), and everyone knows Wiggins was the worst all-star starter ever, at this point. So it will be impressive that Curry at age 34-35 can get this squad to a Finals, as where Bron... partly due to his playstyle... has had to frequently blow up teams for the past decade.

Peesonally, I just hope for more variety from these top 10 lists as well. I'm tired of the generic MJ, lebron, Kareem, Magic, Bird, Wilt, Russell, Kobe Shaq Duncan Hakeem type lists. The criteria is all over the place, and some of those players see not scrutinized as much as they should be.
 

mbewane

Knicks: 93 til infinity
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
19,290
Reputation
4,261
Daps
55,750
Reppin
Brussels, Belgium
Bron averaged 3.07 dribbles per touch this year. That was 142nd in the NBA, lower than Steph (4.06 dribbles per touch) and Poole (3.51 dribbles per touch).

How little basketball have you watched to believe that Bron hasn't excelled in a player movement offense? The 2013 Heat were arguably his greatest team and their movement was fantastic.

Don't say shyt just because other people on The Coli told you it was true.

3.07 dribbles PER TOUCH. How many touches per game does he have per game? Then multiply that by 3.07. That's the relevant stat. How little basketball have you watched to really be insinuating the Lakers had better offensive movement and fluidity this year than the Warriors :francis::skip:

And regardless of all that, the hell the Warriors would be doing jeopardizing their future for one or two years of a close to 40 years old Bron
 

Jerz

All Star
Joined
Apr 1, 2018
Messages
3,947
Reputation
310
Daps
11,135
Steph doesn't have to surpass lebron - but its still a better look to go after more championships - without dude on his team. The top dogs are not welcoming this dude so he can tryin stack a few more titles on his way out the door.. Philly might entertain it. But other than that - he gon have to hope for a healthy AD, n gettin off Russ contract/ bringing back 2 solid role players, and convince ring chasing vets to join him on cheap deals, like he always has. Good luck
 

Professor Emeritus

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Supporter
Joined
Jan 5, 2015
Messages
51,331
Reputation
19,930
Daps
204,096
Reppin
the ether
You're ignoring Duncan's flaws. He only has 3 FMVPs, and he also had some so-so finals performances (07, wtf was that? 13 he was part of the choke against the Heat)

03 is held up as this vaunted "carry job" but everyone ignores Dirk Nowitzki and Chris Webber getting hurt, and the Lakers being injured that year.

Breh all that shyt applies 100x to Curry. :dwillhuh:

Curry has ZERO Finals MVPs, nothing but so-so Finals appearances, is part of the '16 collapse which is MUCH more notorious than Duncan's '13 loss, and the injuries to opponents during his big "no Durant" run (or even this year's run) were way worse than '03 Duncan. :comeon:




By 2013-2014, that was a full on ensemble, Duncan wasn't really head and shoulders above everyone else. He had a lot of offensive and defensive support at different stages.

Curry had a lot of offensive and defensive support for every playoff run. In the years where Curry had to carry the team to the extend Duncan did early, the team didn't even get past the first round.



Like I pointed out, Curry still ain't on Duncan's level. And you're talking him passing LeBron? smh
 

HabitualChiller

Enjoying a Long Night of Solace✌
Supporter
Joined
Oct 27, 2016
Messages
17,308
Reputation
4,180
Daps
54,172
Reppin
Somewhere on an Xbox
Lol that's not true imo

If steph gets his 4th chip this year, not only does he tie lebron in ring count, but

  • It would be his 2nd non superteam ring without Durant
  • He would have to go through a 2nd seed Grizzlies and 1st seed 64 win Suns team on the road
  • All with Klay being "a shell of himself"
That won't be enough to put him ahead of course... but it opens the door again. What if next year, Poole and Kuminga make that leap, the team is healthy, and Curry gets out of his shooting slump? We forget that Curry is an MVP level player otherwise. It's NOT impossible that they repeat next year.

If that happens, you really don't think a discussion would be had?
No. He doesn't come near LeBron in statistics or accolades. Plus, LeBron was much more dominant over a longer period of time.

It's a gap between the top 3 players oat and everyone else. You'd essentially need to be dominant from the day you stepped in the league AND be near your peak for a decade in order to warrant even being in the discussion, and that's not counting rings and other awards.

Steph doesn't have enough time.
 

Professor Emeritus

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Supporter
Joined
Jan 5, 2015
Messages
51,331
Reputation
19,930
Daps
204,096
Reppin
the ether
Aside from that, Duncan doesn't really have any strong playoff run either.

:usure:

'99, '03, and '05 were all dominant playoff runs. You're probably distracted on the box score by Duncan's runs coming in that brief window where NBA ball was the absolute slowest its ever been, and because most of Duncan's defensive contribution doesn't show up on the stat sheet. But in those three years Duncan was absolutely carrying the team all the way through the playoffs on both sides of the ball in a manner that Curry has never done, and overcoming some big-time opponents who should have had the advantage (like the Shaq-Kobe Lakers or the defending champ Pistons) in the process.


'99 in the WCSF he tore apart the Shaq-Kobe Lakers to the tune of 29-11-3 and 2 blocks a game in a series where Sean Elliott was his #2 scorer and some of their wins were in the 70s or 80s. Then he dismantled the Knicks in the Finals with 27-14-2 and 2 blocks/game. In the last two games of that series he put up 28-18-3 and 3 blocks, then a 31-9-2 elimination game that they won just 78-77.

'03 he had the 28-12-5 series in upsetting the defending champ Shaq-Kobe Lakers, then 28-17-6 and 3 blocks a game taking down Dirk's Mavs, then a ridiculous 24-17-5 and FIVE blocks a game in the Finals. In the Game 6 close-out game he put up 21-20-10 with 8 blocks in an 88-77 win, leading all players on the court in all of those categories.


Steph has never had a single playoff run that measures up to the 2-way dominance that Duncan showed in '99 and '03. Not to mention Duncan's numerous other dominant series like 27-17-4 and 2 blocks/game against the '01 mavs, 26-11-6 and 6 blocks/game against the '02 Sonics, 29-17-5 and 3 blocks/game against the '02 Lakers, 32-12-4 and 3 blocks/game against the '06 Mavs (the series that ended with Duncan's 41-15-6 and 3 blocks Game 7 failed to win the series only due to Manu's unfortunate foul), 27-14-1 and 4 blocks/game against the '07 Suns.


If Steph wins two more titles with dominant performances in the process and finally gets his Finals MVPs, then he'll be in Duncan territory. He's not there yet.
 

DJ Paul's Arm

Veteran
Joined
Dec 15, 2015
Messages
22,478
Reputation
6,624
Daps
127,932
Reppin
Cali
Man hell nah! We don’t need that cancer on our team. Ol’ my way or the highway having ass nikka. Go back to Cleveland, pull their strings to draft Bronny, have your dream of playing with your son for a year, then GTFOH

:camby:
 

Peruvian Connect

Superstar
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
7,906
Reputation
-1,861
Daps
15,554
Reppin
NULL
No. He doesn't come near LeBron in statistics or accolades. Plus, LeBron was much more dominant over a longer period of time.

It's a gap between the top 3 players oat and everyone else. You'd essentially need to be dominant from the day you stepped in the league AND be near your peak for a decade in order to warrant even being in the discussion, and that's not counting rings and other awards.

Steph doesn't have enough time.
What do you consider dominant? Stats or rings? LeBron was diickrode since day one he sure as hell wasn't dominating.
 

beenz

Rap Guerilla
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
85,206
Reputation
11,440
Daps
198,204
Reppin
The Chi (South Side)
it the warriors are contending without him, why even bother, cuz everyone knows when u get lebron, he's gonna wanna have full control of everything else, especially personnel decisions.
 
Top