So is Everyone in Agreement That The Paul George/Shai trade Was The Absolute WORST Trade in NBA History?

FTBS

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
20,519
Reputation
3,611
Daps
55,989
Reppin
NULL
I hate how this being an all time blunder is blamed on Paul George. George made three all star games and an all nba team during his time in LA. Clippers also made their only WCF during George’s time there. This was an all time bad trade because 1) Shai became a superstar 2)Kawhi never was healthy.

I look at those being the greater issue and not George's play.
This is all on Kawhi. He had Clips bending to his every whim, including load management, and he didnt deliver. Like you said, their best run was with him watching while PG led the way. Everybody was healthy for the 2020 chokejob. If they cash in there, this isnt even a discussion.
 

FTBS

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
20,519
Reputation
3,611
Daps
55,989
Reppin
NULL
The funny thing about it is imagine if the Clippers had kept SGA (like so many people say they should've done, due to hindsight) and Kawhi still joins the team. A championship still isn't guaranteed due to Kawhi constantly being injured over the course of that whole run.
True. But you have a young, healthy superstar and picks.
 

RubioTheCruel

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
22,541
Reputation
2,388
Daps
83,004
Reppin
Brooklyn, NY
In hindsight? It’s one of the worst but let’s paint the whole picture.

Kawhi was fresh of winning a championship and he asked for the Clippers to trade for PG then you make that trade. It’s not like SGA was viewed as some generational draft prospect like Wendy or Zion. PG was a conscience top 10-15 player at the time.

It’s not like at the time of the trade people were outraged that SGA got traded because it made sense on paper.

How many people expected SGA to lead the Thunder to a title? Just goes to show you how hard it is to win a championship. The Clippers swung for the fences and missed. But that’s life.
It's complete results based analysis.

PG just finished top 3 MVP voting, was 1st team all-NBA and all-defense and was only 28. You got Kawhi saying that if you bring him in he's gonna sign there. I'd imagine 29/30 NBA GMs make that move.
 

KFBF

Superstar
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
11,910
Reputation
2,855
Daps
34,907
Reppin
Eagle, Colorado
They shouldn't have traded what they did for PG. But that only happened after KD, Kyrie, and Butler turned Kawhi down. It was Doc Rivers that said PG was available.

People acting like the Clippers would have OKC's roster without the trade aren't worth engaging.


The Luka trade is the worst trade only because Dallas could have got an insane package and they didn't because of Nicos infatuation with AD.
 

Peruvian Connect

Superstar
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
7,490
Reputation
-1,962
Daps
14,472
Reppin
NULL
They shouldn't have traded what they did for PG. But that only happened after KD, Kyrie, and Butler turned Kawhi down. It was Doc Rivers that said PG was available.

People acting like the Clippers would have OKC's roster without the trade aren't worth engaging.


The Luka trade is the worst trade only because Dallas could have got an insane package and they didn't because of Nicos infatuation with AD.
They traded essentially Shai and Jalen Williams for PG. That's not a bad trade. They made other good to great moves,.

And even still it's not the worst. Charlotte traded Kobe for Vlade Divac, Kobe went to 7 finals winning 5. Charlotte ain't did shiit but relocate
 

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
43,413
Reputation
-154
Daps
90,384
Like that changes the fact that it was a bad trade :mjlol:

Clippers traded a future MVP, multiple 1st team all-NBA scoring champ as well as the pick that got OKC Jdub. Dub made an all-star team, all NBA, and all defense. That’s some shyt Kawhi, Jimmy, and CP3 were doing

And Paul George isn’t even on the clippers anymore. Yes, it very well might be the worst trade of all time. Just as bad as the BKN/BOS trade that got Tatum and Brown to the Celtics
All that is hindsight
 

QuintessentialBM

GoldenAgeGamer82 - PSN ID
Joined
Dec 24, 2012
Messages
9,507
Reputation
1,522
Daps
14,410
Reppin
Gamers Paradise
If you add the fact, if Indiana finally closes out the Knicks, the Pacers will have also built an NBA Finals caliber team by trading away Paul George. Indy hated him because he couldn't get them a title as the #1 constantly losing in the second round.

The only reason this isn't the worst trade in sports history YET because it may or may not turn OKC dynastic like the Hershel Walker to Dallas trade OR the Curse of the Bambino trade where the Red Sox went 100+ years withouth winning a title; that will take time.

This trade is worse than the Boston/Brooklyn trade, IMO.
 

Damnshow

Veteran
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
19,476
Reputation
5,160
Daps
85,208
How many of you envisioned SGA becoming the MVP when that trade happened? Back then those kind of superteam build trades happened a lot. I read something about Doc Rivers saying he told them not to trade SGA...get the fukk outta here :mjlol: trying to pretend like he was Nostradamus.

SGA went to the perfect spot where he was given keys to lead.

Clippers were desperate to stay in the win now mode thinking they would win over some LA fans. The gamble didn't work because Kawhi broke down too soon with all the injuries and PG never got anywhere close to top 3 MVP votes guy he was in that one season in OKC. They gambled on injury prone players and it didn't work out this time.

Sometimes it works out pretty well like Raptors winning a championship with Kawhi who just happened to be healthy that year. Or Lakers winning a championship with AD before he returned to his street clothes gimmick again. And then there are gambles that don't pay off like Knicks signing Amare who was like a fan favorite for one and a half season, etc.

Clippers are just a cursed ass franchise with so so medical staff on top of that. If you look at Clippers history, there's been so many players there affected by injuries, from Elton Brand to Kawhi/PG, etc.
 
Top