Disgustya Stallone
Man Who Owns 2 Microwaves
.... What else us in the discussion besides Godfather I, and Raging Bull?
So.... is it universally accepted that GOODFELLAS is the GOAT movie of all time?
- Thread starter Disgustya Stallone
- Start date
.... What else us in the discussion besides Godfather I, and Raging Bull?
Saysumthinfunnymike
VOTE!!!
Breh there ain't no consensus, there are several contenders depending on who you ask 
That said Goodfellas might be my favorite or at least way up there. The acting, writing and especially the direction. Scorcese shyt on everyone with that joint. The one shot tracking scene as Henry and Karen are walking in is one of the GOAT scenes in all of film. It's damn near impossible to pull off like he did it.
The musical choices were piff. Other scenes like the Billy Batts
That said Goodfellas might be my favorite or at least way up there. The acting, writing and especially the direction. Scorcese shyt on everyone with that joint. The one shot tracking scene as Henry and Karen are walking in is one of the GOAT scenes in all of film. It's damn near impossible to pull off like he did it.
The musical choices were piff. Other scenes like the Billy Batts
Goodfellas
Juice
Killer Klowns From Outerspace
Juice
Killer Klowns From Outerspace
Nah it's either Godfather or Shawshank Redemption
Saysumthinfunnymike
VOTE!!!
I don't want to bash Shawshank but there's some parts there where I felt was a lil hokey and for me it's like a 9.5/10
Here Comes the Pain
Superstar
The godfather will always be the goat followed by training day.
Breh there ain't no consensus, there are several contenders depending on who you ask
That said Goodfellas might be my favorite or at least way up there. The acting, writing and especially the direction. Scorcese shyt on everyone with that joint. The one shot tracking scene as Henry and Karen are walking in is one of the GOAT scenes in all of film. It's damn near impossible to pull off like he did it.
The musical choices were piff. Other scenes like the Billy Batts
Best shyt was it was all real people in real life. The real life mobsters were even more ruthless.
Funny scenes were Henry givin the beats to Karen's neighbor and obviously the "funny" scene in the restaurant. Read that scene was all improv.
BelieveBeOK
Superstar
Nope. Not even the best film starring Robert De Niro.
Jacaveli The Don
Superstar
Goodfellas is up there, not one fake scene in that film, everything feels real.
But, The Godfather + II take it for me. Theres a reason why it is high up the list of every critic. And its a gangster film, think about that for a minute. A GANGSTER FILM is top of nearly every critic's list. Pacino was in top form in both, when you finish watching them, you feel like a don yourself. And its more about power rather than killing. De Niro bodies Part II aswell.
But, The Godfather + II take it for me. Theres a reason why it is high up the list of every critic. And its a gangster film, think about that for a minute. A GANGSTER FILM is top of nearly every critic's list. Pacino was in top form in both, when you finish watching them, you feel like a don yourself. And its more about power rather than killing. De Niro bodies Part II aswell.
There's no"consensus" but godfather is at the top of most lists. As it should be
MR. Conclusion
All Star
If I were to judge a movie by the amount of times I've seen it then yes.
I literally know every line in this movie.
The only other movie that's close is scarface and then T2 after that.
I literally know every line in this movie.
The only other movie that's close is scarface and then T2 after that.
Disgustya Stallone
Man Who Owns 2 Microwaves
whoa.... for real?I prefer Casino over it but not by much
