So who's gonna win MVP this season?

Who wins MVP


  • Total voters
    188
  • Poll closed .

SchoolboyC

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 27, 2014
Messages
25,612
Reputation
4,885
Daps
108,847
@SchoolboyC edit poll to take out Lillard, Towns or George and include Jimmy

:whew:

It wouldn't let me delete any of them so I just added him, but I think the poll a little too far gone to matter anyway.

That said, I wouldn't even be mad at Jimmy being be a 2x Most Improved Player winner
 

ManBearPig

half man half bearpig
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
27,573
Reputation
-2,690
Daps
30,035
Reppin
Chi-town
yeah but it won't happen this year
they don't play that any more

nikka how u know. Its the same circumstance:stopitslime:


Billups: not that good
Duncan and Dirk: stacked teams
Kobe: Lakers didn't win much

DeMar DeRozan: not that good
lebron, curry, and KD: stacked teams
Westbrook: thunder not gonna win a lot

I got kawhi winning it this year anyway:yeshrug:

Like Nash when Amare went out, harden lost his big man
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
90,502
Reputation
10,566
Daps
243,332
I think you're severely mistaken if you think him choosing to sign with the best team in the league will not hurt him in MVP discussions at least for this season.
As I've said, you're putting far too much weight into what happened last season/offseason, and not enough of what happens this season. With each passing day, that 'record breaking 73-win team" narrative will be further drowned out in favor of Durant's all-time great efficiency, historic play and his contributions to the Warriors as how they're built now. That will be at the forefront when the voting period comes around.
The Warriors have proven that they don't need Kevin Durant to be great, that they can be a record breaking team without him, people are not gonna just brush that to the side and ignore all of that. It will be taken into account, but only to a certain extent.
That "certain extent" you've made abundantly clear is that he has no chance at all. I'm arguing that he has a great chance if the Warriors finish as the #1 seed - history dictates so.
The Clippers right now are on pace to win 67-68 games, if that holds true, you really think CP3 & Durant would get an equal amount of praise?
That all depends on whom the voters deem contributes the most to both teams at the end of the season. One thing's for sure, Griffin will need to continue to be their leading scorer if they want to keep winning at this pace, and therefore he'll take a lot of praise away from CP3 that he'd otherwise get in favor over Durant.
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
90,502
Reputation
10,566
Daps
243,332
Its going to be Kawhi then Lol.

He finished 2nd last year so so why is it out of the question for him to win it this year? His numbers went up too
He finished 2nd last season largely due to the fact that the Spurs finished as the 2nd seed. Anything less than that and he's not going to win MVP this season.
 

SchoolboyC

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 27, 2014
Messages
25,612
Reputation
4,885
Daps
108,847
As I said you're putting far too much weight into what happened last season/offseason, and not enough of what happens this season. With each passing day, that 'record breaking 73-win team" narrative will be further drowned out in favor of Durant's all-time great efficiency, historic play and his contributions to the Warriors as how they're built now. That will be at the forefront when voting comes round.

That "certain extent" you've made abundantly clear is that he has no chance at all.

That all depends on whom the voters deem contributes the most to both teams at the end of the season. One thing's for sure, Griffin will need to continue to be their leading scorer if they want to keep winning at this pace, and therefore he'll take a lot of praise away from CP3 that he'd otherwise get in favor over Durant.

What happened last season/offseason is absolutely going to be a factor. This was not your average offseason. I don't see how it's going to be just completely brushed aside that Durant joined a team that was already legendary without him. Again, I'm not talking about my personal opinion, I'm talking about how I think it will be voted. From an objective standpoint, yes it really shouldn't matter, but that's just not how this shyt works. The media has biases and they form narratives, and I'm really not seeing a scenario where Durant joining an already stacked squad doesn't hurt him this year.

I don't think Griffin being the leading scorer would hurt CP3 at all. After all, Steve Nash won two MVP's without being the leading scorer on his team. He's viewed as the leader of the team by the masses regardless.
 

The Fire

way more chemical than political
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2014
Messages
33,770
Reputation
10,479
Daps
139,255
Reppin
brooklyn
nikka how u know. Its the same circumstance:stopitslime:


Billups: not that good
Duncan and Dirk: stacked teams
Kobe: Lakers didn't win much

DeMar DeRozan: not that good
lebron, curry, and KD: stacked teams
Westbrook: thunder not gonna win a lot

I got kawhi winning it this year anyway:yeshrug:

Like Nash when Amare went out, harden lost his big man
The award especially in recent years has gravitated towards the "best player on best team" prototype
 
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
90,502
Reputation
10,566
Daps
243,332
What happened last season/offseason is absolutely going to be a factor. This was not your average offseason. I don't see how it's going to be just completely brushed aside that Durant joined a team that was already legendary without him.
It won't be completely be brushed aside, but it certainly WON'T take precedence over what happens this season.
Again, I'm not talking about my personal opinion, I'm talking about how I think it will be voted. From an objective standpoint, yes it really shouldn't matter, but that's just not how this shyt works. The media has biases and they form narratives, and I'm really not seeing a scenario where Durant joining an already stacked doesn't hurt him this year.
This is the problem here, you made this thread based upon what you thought the narrative was at the time - whatever narrative and bias you think existed prior to the season starting isn't going to be nearly as strong 10 months later. All that will matter is what the most dominant basketball fictive will be when it comes time to vote, and that's usually based around play during the season - not what took place before it. Will the 'Durant joining a stacked team' spot play a part? Of course, just as every bias built from previous seasons (voters simply not liking players, valuing different stats that favor other players more than others, valuing both ends of the floor rather than just offensive play etc etc) plays a part too.
I don't think Griffin being the leading scorer would hurt CP3 at all. After all, Steve Nash won two MVP's without being the leading scorer on his team. He's viewed as the leader of the team by the masses regardless.
I wouldn't really use Nash as the rule, especially since i) they aren't the same voters/voting has changed since then ii) we don't know what tag will be placed on BG as the season goes along iii) rarely ever to non-leading scorers win MVP.
 

SchoolboyC

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 27, 2014
Messages
25,612
Reputation
4,885
Daps
108,847
It won't be completely be brushed aside, but it certainly WON'T take precedence over what happens this season.

This is the problem here, you made this thread based upon what you thought the narrative was at the time - whatever narrative and bias you think existed prior to the season starting isn't going to be nearly as strong 10 months later. All that will matter is what the most dominant basketball fictive will be when it comes time to vote, and that's usually based around play during the season - not what took place before it. Will the 'Durant joining a stacked team' spot play a part? Of course, just as every bias built from previous seasons (voters simply not liking players, valuing different stats that favor other players more than others, valuing both ends of the floor rather than just offensive play etc etc) plays a part too.

I stand firm that him joining the Warriors will negatively affect his MVP campaign this season, and it will factor in to why he will not win it. At this point there's not much that I or you can say that hasn't already been said, so we'll just have to agree to disagree and see what happens in the spring :manny:

I wouldn't really use Nash as the rule, especially since i) they aren't the same voters/voting has changed since then ii) we don't know what tag will be placed on BG as the season goes along iii) rarely ever to non-leading scorers win MVP.

Well I'm not trying to campaign for CP3 to win MVP, but yes as of now I do believe that if the Clippers win in the high 60's like they're currently on pace to do, it will be him that gets most of the glory, regardless of if he leads them in scoring or not, which he hasn't done since he's been with them btw.
 

ManBearPig

half man half bearpig
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
27,573
Reputation
-2,690
Daps
30,035
Reppin
Chi-town
The award especially in recent years has gravitated towards the "best player on best team" prototype

KD wasn't on those warriors teams in the last 2 seasons. I told you they are going to cancel each other out unless one gets hurt and the other carried the load and help that team wins 65+ games
 

ManBearPig

half man half bearpig
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
27,573
Reputation
-2,690
Daps
30,035
Reppin
Chi-town
I stand firm that him joining the Warriors will negatively affect his MVP campaign this season, and it will factor in to why he will not win it. At this point there's not much that I or you can say that hasn't already been said, so we'll just have to agree to disagree and see what happens in the spring :manny:



Well I'm not trying to campaign for CP3 to win MVP, but yes as of now I do believe that if the Clippers win in the high 60's like they're currently on pace to do, it will be him that gets most of the glory, regardless of if he leads them in scoring or not, which he hasn't done since he's been with them btw.

Clippers ain't winning no high 60's breh :mjlol:
 
Top