Stephen A Smith Says NBA Players Have Told Him They Would Feel Unsafe Playing In A City Like Memphis

Harry B

Veteran
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
33,975
Reputation
-786
Daps
69,244
Memphis has been a war zone for 30+ years..

we gettin fake outraged now about SAS's comments?
Miraculously, athletes in these warzone cities managed to survive. And aren’t victims of crimes more than in any other city. God must be watching over them. Now that it’s established that they are gods chosen people with guardian angels since they manage to walk through war zones scot free, why would they start being afraid in 2025.


I didn’t even think about the dumbest thing he said. He said they need to clean up the city cause he knows some nba players are afraid. No regards given to the millions who can’t afford to live in gated communities far from fukkery :snoop:
 

Shadow King

Quiet N***a Loud Choppa
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
44,124
Reputation
3,832
Daps
88,655
Reppin
Hometown of Cherokee at Law
"Nice" is one of those eye of the beholder things. There are dozens of thousands of people in Memphis who are millionaires, they live somewhere, and they not all out in the suburbs. Historically Poplar and some of those Midtown boulevards and cross streets were full of mini-mansions. Whether thats nice or not, I really don't care enough to debate it, homie said aint no nice areas in Memphis and thats why he left...

That's cool for him. It's mf's who have way more money than him and will never leave Memphis, so saying aint no nice areas is a him thing. And its also inflammatory because we know black cities are stigmatized, so running around saying a black city as large as Memphis directly plays into the image of Memphis that mf's are defending themselves against...

I would never live in Memphis again but as someone who has and spent ample time there, I ain't letting nikkas get off with "there's no nice areas there" because its obvious that its not true. Its not fukking Tupelo 🤣

Fair point on CT being an NY suburb but Hartford is closer to Mass than NY and is historically the most relevant city in that state, same way Memphis was historically the most important city in Tennessee. It's cache is muted being between Boston and New York but Baltimore's is also muted being between DC and Philly, it happens. If Memphis, New Orleans, and St Louis were all 100 miles or less from each other, you'd view Memphis in the same light you view Hartford, because as it is its lost cache within its state and has never had the cultural resonance St Louis (which hosted the first World's Fair or some shyt 110 years ago) and New Orleans (one of the first and largest immigration ports in the US dating to the 18th century)....any clout or cache Memphis has, has never been on the level of Nola or StL, and that's woth it a good distance from those cities...

Reverse Hartford and Memphis' locations and they have the same story, Memphis wouldn't be a bigger deal in New England and Hartford wouldn't be a bigger deal on the Mississippi...

I don't really care about physical size either but when you pointed out Hartford's size, you gotta point out that Memphis in the same land area as Hartford (18 sq miles), has the same population as Hartford, and probably less. Memphis has that large population for generations because southern cities have always liberally annexed all available land around them to generate population. Areas that would be suburbs on the coasts or the Midwest, are "in the city" in southern cities, because they are all hundreds of sq miles, many of that mileage lightly populated...
Those millionaires have probably been rooted in the area for generations. They can have more money than @The_Sheff , for a 25 y/o new money multimillionaire and where they may want to be has to be considered vs someone whose great-grandfather made them millionaires in 1930-something.

You just said you're never living in Memphis again. You also have comments in other threads regarding cities where you've said Memphis is overrated just for the sake of it being majority black and cats trying to take pride in it when there's nothing there and too many issues. You're doing the exact same thing you're doing right now.

Baltimore's relationship with Philly and DC is nowhere near as lopsided as the Hartford-New York-Boston connection. Nor would Memphis get wiped out that bad by NOLA and STL. If that were the case you wouldn't be going to bat the way you are now. It holds a cultural significance that isn't relegated to its state.

A city of 600K in New England is absolutely a big deal. Only Boston is larger. This is disingenuous.

You can't cut city size to try to compare it. They're not the same class of city. If that's the case let me say Newark is in the same weight class as Detroit. While there are economic and cultural phenomena that are shared, we know they are not the same class. Hartford is literally 1/5 of Memphis.
 

KFBF

Superstar
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
13,363
Reputation
4,381
Daps
39,588
Reppin
Eagle, Colorado
John Holliner (ex-Grizzilies VP of basketball ops and creator of PER) was on a podcast and was pretty dismissive of SAS comments. Didn't even want to talk about them really. Said Memphis had a harder time getting people to get there than getting them to stay. Also said players live in gated community but I can't recall the name of the area.

Edit: pulled this from podcast transcript

“From my personal experience, getting players to come there was much more difficult than getting players to stay there.

Right. Yeah.

And then the thing a lot of talking heads, I think, don't realize is the players all live in Germantown, in gated communities. They're not walking around on Beale Street. You know, like their experience is totally different.”

From Hollinger & Duncan NBA Show - NBA Basketball Podcast: Bane Trade, KD Trade, Draft Boards, Jun 18, 2025

This material may be protected by copyright.
 

The_Sheff

A Thick Sauce N*gga
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
27,024
Reputation
5,503
Daps
125,515
Reppin
ATL to MEM
I would never live in Memphis again but as someone who has and spent ample time there, I ain't letting nikkas get off with "there's no nice areas there" because its obvious that its not true. Its not fukking Tupelo 🤣

And im not letting you off the hook by asking you to name the area a young black male in Memphis would want to live. A young black male with a family who has no other ties to the city.

Memphis is a city where the people living there have family ties to the city, and the ones who dont are only there for work experience and then they moving the fukk out. Tell me im wrong.
 

MikelArteta

Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
264,003
Reputation
34,895
Daps
806,461
Reppin
Goatganda the pearl of Africa
And im not letting you off the hook by asking you to name the area a young black male in Memphis would want to live. A young black male with a family who has no other ties to the city.

Memphis is a city where the people living there have family ties to the city, and the ones who dont are only there for work experience and then they moving the fukk out. Tell me im wrong.



Is this a bad area ?

Galloway gardens


Never been to Memphis all I really know is Graceland and Lorraine motel
 
Last edited:

RennisDeynolds

I am untethered and my rage knows no bounds!
Joined
Feb 2, 2017
Messages
42,099
Reputation
7,720
Daps
122,706
Reppin
Paddys Pub
So to recap this thread, we got a breh @The_Sheff that actually lived in Memphis saying yeah SAS maybe exaggerated but Memphis really is like that. Then we got a bunch of other posters who maybe visited saying he wrong


:laff:

Gorilla and all the rappers from Memphis even say shyt can get dicey quick in Memphis bc the way the city is layed out.

You'll be in a nice place on one street and the next street over is a bad area
 
Top