SZA talks about how Punch @ TDE restricted what songs were and weren't on "SOS".

LevelUp

๐‘Šโ„Ž๐‘Ž๐‘ก ๐ป๐‘Ž๐‘๐‘๐‘’๐‘›๐‘’๐‘‘ ๐‘ก๐‘œ ๐‘กโ„Ž๐‘’ ๐‘Š๐‘œ๐‘Ÿ๐‘™๐‘‘
Joined
Nov 5, 2013
Messages
85,447
Reputation
44,040
Daps
120,948









I'm going to post my summary/impression of the audio, because I know everyone is going to react to the headline without listening to it.

  • It isn't just Punch, it's Rob (who produced on "damn near everything" on the album, and is also SZA's audio engineer) who will give feedback on what parts of a song/songs need to remain and what need to be cut.
  • SZA says that some of the twitter favorites don't show up on the album because Punch says they've already been leaked/out for years, or some songs sound too alike.
  • SZA says at the end that tracklisting/sequencing is one of her biggest weaknesses, and that Punch is an expert at tracklisting. SZA says she views herself as a storyline, and can't really string together storylines for her albums.
 

dora_da_destroyer

Master Baker
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
66,580
Reputation
17,200
Daps
274,554
Reppin
Oakland
She got 23 songs on her album, most being 2-3 mins, what songs did he force you to keep long and songs did he force offโ€ฆshut the fukk up.

The Punch SZA publicity beef angle is so fukking annoying, they got a hit album on their hands but keep the negative spin as part of their promo :why:
 
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
69,287
Reputation
30,674
Daps
411,009
Reppin
Ft. Stewart, Ga
Basically she writes and sings and Punch is in charge of everything else

Sounds like standard A&R/Management work to me. Not every artist is a genius who has a top to bottom vision for their albums.

I could see Jay Rock being similar with allowing Punch or someone within TDE to regulate tracklistings and sequencing.

Kendrick and Ab-Soul more than likely dictate their work from end to end. Especially Kendrick. His work always comes across as a singular creative vision.

Schoolboy Q could go either way.
 

LevelUp

๐‘Šโ„Ž๐‘Ž๐‘ก ๐ป๐‘Ž๐‘๐‘๐‘’๐‘›๐‘’๐‘‘ ๐‘ก๐‘œ ๐‘กโ„Ž๐‘’ ๐‘Š๐‘œ๐‘Ÿ๐‘™๐‘‘
Joined
Nov 5, 2013
Messages
85,447
Reputation
44,040
Daps
120,948

Solo_87

All Star
Joined
Jul 3, 2018
Messages
2,205
Reputation
205
Daps
4,324
Basically she writes and sings and Punch is in charge of everything else

Sounds like standard A&R/Management work to me. Not every artist is a genius who has a top to bottom vision for their albums.

I could see Jay Rock being similar with allowing Punch or someone within TDE to regulate tracklistings and sequencing.

Kendrick and Ab-Soul more than likely dictate their work from end to end. Especially Kendrick. His work always comes across as a singular creative vision.

Schoolboy Q could go either way.

Yea

Was looking over the writing credits

Thought it was interesting. More hands in the pot compared to CTRL

1. SOS

Written by SZA, Jay Versace, Rob Bisel, Gabriel Samuel Hardeman
Produced by Jay Versace
Contains a sample of โ€œUntil I Found The Lordโ€ as performed by Gabriel Hardeman Delegation

2. Kill Bill

Written by SZA, Rob Bisel, Carter Lang
Produced by Rob Bisel & Carter Lang

3. Seek & Destroy

Written by SZA, Rob Bisel, Cody Fayne [thankgod4cody], Tyran Donaldson [Scum], Carter Lang
Produced by Rob Bisel, thankgod4cody, Scum & Carter Lang

4. Low

Written by SZA, Rob Bisel, Alessandro Buccellat, Joseph Pincus [Aire Atlantica]
Produced by Rob Bisel, Alessandro Buccellati & Aire Atlantica

5. Love Language

Written by SZA, Cody Fayne [thankgod4cody], Carter Lang, Jakob Rabitsch, Anthony Clemons, Jr., Rob Bisel, Pharrell Williams, Tyrone Griffin, Chad Hugo, Jazzae De Waal
Produced by, thankgod4cody, Carter Lang & Yakob
Contains an interpolation of โ€œHit Differentโ€

 

Guvnor

Da Speculative Spectacleยฎ
Joined
Jan 17, 2017
Messages
24,293
Reputation
5,257
Daps
34,982
Reppin
BKLYN
That south Detroit song wouldn't fit on the album and isn't that good to be more than a skit tbh. Put that shyt as a bonus track.

Joni didn't need to be on the album cause it was put out for years ago indeed and didn't hit like I hate you which was the one that caught on. Joni could have just been a street single cause the full song is already out.!

With that said Punch said in his Math Hoffa interview he tells the artist to blame him for things like this but he doesn't ever hold an artist back. I'm sure he helped her sequence this album and it was already too long, everything couldn't make it lol. She just didn't want to be the one to tell her fans that everything couldn't make it lol.
 

Ahadi

Veteran
Joined
Aug 7, 2019
Messages
24,671
Reputation
3,760
Daps
99,978
Sheโ€™s need an EP

Cause sheโ€™s right, her sequencing isnโ€™t the best
 

FunkDoc1112

Heavily Armed
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
20,780
Reputation
6,766
Daps
108,355
Reppin
The 718
Basically she writes and sings and Punch is in charge of everything else

Sounds like standard A&R/Management work to me. Not every artist is a genius who has a top to bottom vision for their albums.

I could see Jay Rock being similar with allowing Punch or someone within TDE to regulate tracklistings and sequencing.

Kendrick and Ab-Soul more than likely dictate their work from end to end. Especially Kendrick. His work always comes across as a singular creative vision.

Schoolboy Q could go either way.
I imagine that's probably the case for a lot of rappers starting out, especially back in the day. First album more curated by a third-party and then they start expanding their own vision. Like with Nas for example, I imagine with Illmatic Large Pro and MC Serch probably had a bigger hand in getting it all together, and then It Was Written was more himself
 
Top