You continue to prove your stupidity. How can either one be the "rightful" Cy Young Winner? Is one a descendent of Cy Young, so he should inherit the award? Stupid. Like last year? You're insinuating that Greinke has "started to falter"? No. Greinke has stayed at the same level all year long. Never better (though how can he be?) and never worse. If anything, one could argue that he's becoming a victim of his own consistency, as everyone is getting recency bias with Arrieta's play of late.
The fact is that there's no wrong choice. And if someone votes for Kershaw (which him not being mentioned here is kind of insane too), that wouldn't be wrong either. I hate the fact that ppl feel the need to make an absolute statement about something that is literally splitting hairs. If Arrieta wins the award, will that be right? Yes. If Greinke wins the award, will that be right? Yes. They're both having ridiculously good seasons, and if the world were just, they'd share the award, but the odds of that are long. Regardless, the person that finishes 2nd will in no way be diminshed. lol @ "honorable runner up". I mean, seriously...smh.