Muslims, Christians, and Jews lived in peace in palestine until the British Mandate, after that nothing was the same. (btw it was under muslim rule when it was peaceful
)
The Israeli Perspective: The Middle East Problem
- Thread starter Type Username Here
- Start date
)
88m3
Fast Money & Foreign Objects
Muslims, Christians, and Jews lived in peace in palestine until the British Mandate, after that nothing was the same. (btw it was under muslim rule when it was peaceful
rewrite history to support your religion, brehs
Type Username Here
Not a new member
More from al-Husseini:
Claim harmony when leaders advocate and support the genocide of others brehs .
What you're effectively saying is that you want to go back to a time where Jews were dhimmis in the Ottoman Empire, i.e second-class citizens. They can get their little synagogue, some protection from the state if they pay their tax, but not hold any power or saying into the affairs of the state or government. Is that correct?
prove us wrong. There were bums on yahoo disagreeing and citing stuff that happened after wwI, guess they didnt know the date the British Mandate was created.
Disagree with facts brehs.
breh palestine hasnt been free since the British Mandate, everything you listed is after the British mandate was created.
Type Username Here
Not a new member
Muslims, Christians, and Jews lived in peace in palestine until the British Mandate, after that nothing was the same. (btw it was under muslim rule when it was peaceful
They lived in relative peace, but they were essentially held as second-class citizens. They had no true self-authority as a community. When they tried to establish self-authority, issues began to escalate. It was not harmony. Maybe we have different definitions of the word harmony. You are right in saying that it's definitely not present-day Israel/Palestine conflict, the violent is overwhelming now, but to act like it was some utopia of religious/ethnic freedom for all mankind is just as absurd friend.
Shouldn't even go back to what was or continue forward with what is. I know this is next to impossible but I keep goin back to the shyt I said in the beginning of this thread. It should just be one neutral UN administered states for all groups with neither names nor flags. UN should control things for a few generation until genuine and lasting equal governance can be be fostered.
I know what you're saying, but you have to realize minority groups always face slight discrimination anywhere. Even here in the U.S. But to have 100% discrimination, calls for genocide, etc... is different from a group that makes up less than 10% of a population not being able to hold office.
Type Username Here
Not a new member
Yea, a No-State Solution might be the most feasible solution besides Israel completely wiping out the Palestinian people from those lands. It's going to take reforming the concept of the security council though. The Security Council procedures and powers are extremely outdated and unfair.
Do you realize how many zionist terrorists, and I use that word in its proper sense, not the way it is used today, were in palestine at the time killing innocents and masterminding attacks? You think our land was conquered in 1 year? I dont have to post how many terrorist attacks were orchestrated against my people in that time. And this man was against the zionism agenda, and years later he is proved to be correct in his assertion as the zionists finally took control of our country. You're acting as if we have no right to defend our country from infiltration and or conquerors. If these zionists wouldnt have invaded, would they have faced persecution? Ofcourse not. There have been jews christians and muslims living side by side for years. Go ask the palestinian jews and christians whose side they on.
Type Username Here
Not a new member
Agreed friend. Let us not use the word harmony for such things then right?
American muslims have their own communities, can practice their faith, can hold office, and have many other equal protections. Plenty of American Jews, Atheists, Muslims, Christians are also neighbors and friends. It doesn't meant that there is not egregious actions by the state towards American Muslims or that there is total religious harmony. Same with race. No need to sell false utopias for propaganda reasons. What is occurring in Gaza is reason enough to demonstrate clear atrocities by the Israeli government in the present.
I hate to say it, but this is one of those topics where I have to take anything said by a Jew/Israeli/Zionist or a Arab/Palestinian/Muslim on this topic with a grain of salt because you don't know how much is true and how much is part of the PR/propaganda war.
Type Username Here
Not a new member
The man you're defending clearly advocated the genocide of all jews. It's there in his own words.
Yeah that's why I have next to no faith that this could ever happen. As terrible as it is to suggest, the worst this conflict gets the sooner the Security Council would have to seriously consider fixing this several decades old mistake. But it's crazy not enough people suggest a neutral state solution. Reza Aslan kinda alluded to it but he didn't go so far as to say that it was a remedy but rather an inevitability.
The Jews won't leave and imo they have a right to live in their holy land as do Muslims and Christians or anyone else for that matter, the Palestinians won't be wiped out and put under this brutality and degradation anymore. Neither of em should have power til they can create a peaceful society for themselves and each other and a 2 state solution at this point is a joke and a slower method of Israel gettin what it wants anyway. The worst the Israelis get in this conflict the worse the international community and its leaders look for enabling this type of show simply out of fear of its petulant bratty monster of a creation.
No he wasn't, he was against Zionism. The term wasn't as common back then as it is today. Zionist claimed to be Jews and hijacked this religion to push their agenda.
What you're missing and completely ignoring here is that, Palestinians never asked for this. They were invaded by the Zionists and the west and forced to act in self defense means. Before the Zionist agenda, everything was cool. Once the Zionists started their terror war, we had to defend ourselves and try to stop the Zionist offensive that was put in front of us. Everybody is acting like its criminal to defend yourself from an occupying force, when in fact it's the noble thing to do. And you still didn't answer my question of why the Jews and Christians of Palestine are on our side. Why are the real Jews supporting Palestine and against the state of Israel? Do you see any Muslims in support of israel?
Muslims, Christians, and Jews lived in peace in palestine until the British Mandate, after that nothing was the same. (btw it was under muslim rule when it was peaceful
