The Majority Report with Sam Seder Thread

[AquaCityBoy]

Captured by the audience. Instead of admitting Ana Kasparian got this one issue right, she has to pretend “males” are “women"

fukk you and Ana Kasparian

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

fukk you and Ana Kasparian

 

[Pull Up the Roots]

This is an L

fukk JK Rowling and any idiot rallying around her.

Brianna Ghey in the time of J.K. Rowling

Opinion: “It is hard enough to be a transgender person without the constant hate and bigotry that is constantly spewed upon them, and it’s despicable that there are people who tirelessly work to make transgender people’s lives even worse.”

dailycollegian.com

https://medium.com/@transylvania/fukk-you-j-k-rowling-and-others-4a943aa2a558

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

fukk JK Rowling and any idiot rallying around her.

Brianna Ghey in the time of J.K. Rowling

Opinion: “It is hard enough to be a transgender person without the constant hate and bigotry that is constantly spewed upon them, and it’s despicable that there are people who tirelessly work to make transgender people’s lives even worse.”

dailycollegian.com

https://medium.com/@transylvania/fukk-you-j-k-rowling-and-others-4a943aa2a558

Murder and violence against individuals are illegal and violations of human rights.

 

[Outlaw]

As she should

This is a serious question, can someone be trans racial? @Loose you can answer this one too

 

[AquaCityBoy]

This is a serious question, can someone be trans racial?

@☑︎#VoteDemocrat

 

[Outlaw]

@☑︎#VoteDemocrat

Seriously though would you acknowledge a white man being trans racial if they chose to identify as a black man?

Additionally, would you be a c00n if as a black man you discriminate against a trans racial black man because you call them a white man?

 

[Loose]

This is a serious question, can someone be trans racial? @Loose you can answer this one too

Leave me out of yall trans fighting breh

 

[Pull Up the Roots]

Seriously though would you acknowledge a white man being trans racial if they chose to identify as a black man?

Additionally, would you be a c00n if as a black man you discriminate against a trans racial black man because you call them a white man?

The transracial vs transgender analogy doesn't really hold up. Gender dysphoria is a recognized medical and psychological condition. It's something people experience deeply and persistently, and there are established medical frameworks for understanding and treating it. The same can't be said for someone claiming to be transracial. Trans people aren't choosing something, they're navigating something that's internally real to them, and often painful without support or affirmation.

Race, by contrast, is about how society categorizes us based on appearance and ancestry. It's externally assigned and tied to history, power, and collective experience, not something someone can just internally feel their way into. The analogy ignores that context. It flattens both race and gender into vibes or choices, and that's not how either one works.

 

[storyteller]

Agreed.

The video is literally called “Biden paved the way for Mahmoud’s deportation”

"Paved the way" doesn't mean "this is all his fault." Which is the whole point of the "give an inch he'll take a yard" concept.

He’s going to take anyone’s premise and push it a mile further. He’s going to take anyone’s “rhetoric” and distort it. He has done that numerous times in the past before Biden and continues to do it now. There is no precedent to establish if he literally blames someone else every single time.

Sure. In this instance, Biden treated protests like antisemitism. Then Trump used that line of thinking to attack campuses and deport kids. Which is exactly how "Biden paved the way for Mahmoud's deportation."

You aren't refuting that by saying "well Trump just does that." You're basically co-signing it by acknowledging it's a common Trump behavior.

There was nothing special Biden did but not be a Trump cultist.

True. Biden didn't do anything special and was generally a forgettable president if not for speaking like an invalid toward the latter half of his term.

If the point is “he’s going to do fascism no matter what”, then yes I agree with you but that’s such a basic agreed upon point it isn’t worth anyone’s time much less a video interview. If the point is he used Biden’s rhetoric for his own means, cool I guess? He’s going to use anyone’s rhetoric for his own means so what are we talking about here?

There you go. You figured it out. The point is Biden's rhetoric was the launchpad for the deportations of college students and the revocation of student visas. That's what the video is discussing. You acknowledge it's true, then there ain't much else to talk about.

if it were a Trump republican critique you wouldn’t bring up the person giving an inch in the first place. That’s the premise of the phrase, that the person giving the inch created the spark.

Actually, "Biden gave an inch, Trump took a yard" explicitly means that what Trump did is exponentially worse than what Biden did.

I’ll let you have the last word man go for it. MR got the computers puting so more power to them

Last word, oh sweet, thanks! I'll use it to say that Biden's term ended with Trump back in power, which marks his presidency as a failure.

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

This is the corny shyt I’m talking about

Matt Lech is the average Kendrick fan

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

@☑︎#VoteDemocrat

I’m black. You dont know what women are.

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

The transracial vs transgender analogy doesn't really hold up. Gender dysphoria is a recognized medical and psychological condition.

Its not.

PhD in Psych wrote this:

I supported trans ideology until I couldn’t anymore

Alicia Hendley bought into gender identity ideology (and went after anyone who challenged her), until she couldn’t ignore the facts any longer.

www.feministcurrent.com

It's something people experience deeply and persistently, and there are established medical frameworks for understanding and treating it. The same can't be said for someone claiming to be transracial. Trans people aren't choosing something, they're navigating something that's internally real to them, and often painful without support or affirmation.

Treating something thats not real doesn’t mean the thing is real.

Are delusions about being a religious prophet validations of the religion?

Race, by contrast, is about how society categorizes us based on appearance and ancestry. It's externally assigned and tied to history, power, and collective experience, not something someone can just internally feel their way into. The analogy ignores that context. It flattens both race and gender into vibes or choices, and that's not how either one works.

Convenient evasion

 

[Pull Up the Roots]

Its not.

PhD in Psych wrote this:

I supported trans ideology until I couldn’t anymore

Alicia Hendley bought into gender identity ideology (and went after anyone who challenged her), until she couldn’t ignore the facts any longer.

www.feministcurrent.com

Treating something thats not real doesn’t mean the thing is real.

Are delusions about being a religious prophet validations of the religion?

Convenient evasion

Stop quoting me, you dumb bigot. Nothing you're saying is based on any real facts.

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

Stop quoting me, you dumb bigot. Nothing you're saying is based on any real facts.

What did I say that was bigoted?