The Official 2024-25 MLB Hot Stove Thread
- Thread starter ineedsleep212
- Start date
tremonthustler1
aka bx_representer
Ichiro Suzuki
CC Sabathia
I want to vote for Felix Hernandez but I don't think I can. He's in that Johan Santana tier. Amazing when he had it. But he just didn't have it for long enough.
There are some good players on the list. Just not Hall of famers.
Lose playing time to Alex Verdugo, brehs.
I have Felix and CC relatively even. They both had 6-7 year runs. CC only had one season with an ERA under 3.00; Felix had three. I don't think I'd vote for either.
CC got 250 wins he should be first ballot.I have Felix and CC relatively even. They both had 6-7 year runs. CC only had one season with an ERA under 3.00; Felix had three. I don't think I'd vote for either.
90s and early 00s pitchers gonna look like how we viewed CY Young era. Because aint nobody under 30 is winning 200 games in my lifetime
tremonthustler1
aka bx_representer
the Martian doesn't kiss Captain Boombox's ass enough
CC's numbers just don't compare to the best of this era: Verlander, Scherzer and Kershaw.
I won't be shocked if he eventually gets in but I wouldn't vote for him.
blues_funk_reggae
Veteran
I'm putting in Ichiro and CC.
I never saw much of Felix, he spent all his career in Seattle and he might as well have been playing on Jupiter.
Every time I did see him he was always mid, never won 20 games, just always came off as mid
Ichiro the GOAT is getting in with 99.99%
I never saw much of Felix, he spent all his career in Seattle and he might as well have been playing on Jupiter.
Every time I did see him he was always mid, never won 20 games, just always came off as mid
Ichiro the GOAT is getting in with 99.99%
Spidey Man
Superstar
Ichiro should be unanimous.
Soto meeting with Philly soon. Deal about to be done soon. I told yall in the beginning of the season he coming to Philly
