Tim Duncan > Kobe Bryant according to ESPN writer

p00rky

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2013
Messages
2,770
Reputation
-920
Daps
4,939
Reppin
San Francisco/Tokyo
NOTE: This isn't a Kobe hate thread.



Of the players in the post-Jordan era of the NBA, it’s a fair argument that Tim Duncan and Kobe Bryant are two of the most accomplished individuals. While LeBron James will no doubt be a part of this discussion once his career is near its end, he has not yet built up a statistical resume quite as hefty as Duncan or Bryant.

Duncan (16 seasons) and Bryant (17) have about the same NBA service time, especially when you consider that Kobe was not much of an impact rookie in 1996-97 (7.6 PPG, 6 starts) while Duncan was the 1997-98 NBA Rookie of the Year, starting all 82 games and averaging 21.1 PPG and 11.9 RPG (keep in mind there were no 20-10 players in the entire NBA this season).

Individual/Regular-Season Success

Bryant is without question the more prolific scorer, averaging five more points for his career than Duncan. However, Duncan won two regular season MVPs (2001-02, 02-03), while Bryant has just one (2007-08). They were in direct competition for Duncan’s MVP awards also, as Bryant finished fifth and third respectively in the MVP voting for Duncan’s two MVP seasons.

While Duncan has a better percentage from the field for his career, Bryant has bested him by one in All-Star Games, All Defensive 1st team selections, and All-NBA 1st teams. In fact, Bryant tied Karl Malone for most 1st team All-NBA selections this season when he picked up his 11th such honor.

Team/Postseason Success

Team success has been plentiful for both players, as both have made the playoffs 16 times. Duncan has never missed the playoffs in his entire career. Bryant, on the other hand, missed the playoffs in the 2004-05 season, ending the season under .500 at 34-48. Since Duncan joined the Spurs in 1997-98, they have never had a winning percentage lower than .610.

Additionally, Duncan’s teams have won at least 50 games in every season of his career except the lockout-shortened 1998-99 season (50 regular season games total), which was the season he won his first NBA title and NBA Finals MVP.

As far as playoff success goes, Bryant has won one more title than Duncan. However, Duncan is currently undefeated in the NBA Finals (4-0) and has one more Finals MVP trophy to his credit.

Advanced Metrics in Historical Context

Advanced metrics also slightly favor Duncan. Duncan has 184.2 career win shares (an estimate of the number of wins a player contributes to his team based on his offense and defense), over 10 more win shares than Bryant does for his career. The Spurs stalwart ranks ninth in win shares all time whereas Bryant is ranked 17th.

Defensive win shares show that Duncan really changes the game on that side of the ball. Duncan’s defensive win shares are 93.5 for his career, fifth-best all time behind Russell, Kareem, Olajuwon and Wilt.

Bryant’s 49.5 defensive win shares rank 46th all time for the sake of context. Again, Bryant is a far superior offensive talent, posting 30 more offensive win shares than Duncan for his career, but in terms of all-time ranks, Bryant is ninth and Duncan is 28th, a much closer disparity than on the defensive end.


Source: Duncan numbers among generation's best - TrueHoop Blog - ESPN

:lupe:
 

I AM WE ARE

Banned
Joined
Jun 15, 2012
Messages
45,317
Reputation
12,398
Daps
135,913
Reppin
The N.O
who has more titles is all that matters to most people

the big fundamental is wonderful at his position

that being said,i'm taking a healthy kobe over healthy duncan

this is a good read though
 

Piff Huxtable

Delaney 2020,2024,2028...
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
9,144
Reputation
1,440
Daps
27,522
sorry but i can't ignore Duncan being out of shape for the last 2 years and choking with all those 57+ win teams

If the team is good i'm riding with Bean for the chip



oh, and 5 > 3 + 1*
 

p00rky

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2013
Messages
2,770
Reputation
-920
Daps
4,939
Reppin
San Francisco/Tokyo
sorry but i can't ignore Duncan being out of shape for the last 2 years and choking with all those 57+ win teams

If the team is good i'm riding with Bean for the chip



oh, and 5 > 3 + 1*

Titles are a team accomplishment at the end of the day. Ask Robert Horry. I certainly wouldn't say Robert Horry was better than Karl Malone, Clyde Drexler, Charles Barkley, etc..
 

GreatestLaker

#FirePelinka
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
22,172
Reputation
1,065
Daps
44,290
This being undefeated in the finals argument is dumb. How is losing before the finals better than losing in the finals? Makes no sense.

5 rings out of 7 Final appearances is better than going 5 out of 5 in the finals. No matter how you cut it.
 

duckbutta

eienaar van mans
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
42,759
Reputation
11,750
Daps
163,826
Reppin
DFW
Gimme Timmy in a no contest...

Has been a top 10 scorer

Has been a top 10 rebounder

Has been a top 10 shot blocker

Plus if you take Kobe, well...don't you also need Phil to coach him and another Hall of Fame big man to play with Kobe...unless you just trying to be the 8th seed or not make the playoffs
 

god shamgod

Veteran
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
37,565
Reputation
6,454
Daps
111,636
Tim Duncan>>>Kobe according to any knowledgeable basketball fans too

There's a reason why the spurs have never missed the playoffs since duncan arrived and when he was injured and was out for the 00 playoffs they lost in the 1st round one year after winning the championship.
 

p00rky

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2013
Messages
2,770
Reputation
-920
Daps
4,939
Reppin
San Francisco/Tokyo
Tim Duncan>>>Kobe according to any knowledgeable basketball fans too

There's a reason why the spurs have never missed the playoffs since duncan arrived and when he was injured and was out for the 00 playoffs they lost one year after winning the championship.
Yeap, and people are going to probably bring up David Robinson even though Robinson was in his early 30s when Duncan arrived
 

Piff Huxtable

Delaney 2020,2024,2028...
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
9,144
Reputation
1,440
Daps
27,522
Titles are a team accomplishment at the end of the day. Ask Robert Horry. I certainly wouldn't say Robert Horry was better than Karl Malone, Clyde Drexler, Charles Barkley, etc..

back in 2007 Spurs fans punched their chest talking about 4 > 3 :mjpls:
 

Dwight Howard

Superstar
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
20,959
Reputation
-3,437
Daps
59,700
Reppin
NULL
Tim Duncan>>>Kobe according to any knowledgeable basketball fans too

There's a reason why the spurs have never missed the playoffs since duncan arrived and when he was injured and was out for the 00 playoffs they lost one year after winning the championship.

images
 

GreatestLaker

#FirePelinka
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
22,172
Reputation
1,065
Daps
44,290
I do agree that Duncan's career so far is better than Kobe's.

That 1 extra MVP and Finals MVP carries a lot of weight.
 
Top