No, none of his points stand.
Joy said that immigrants have lower crime rates. Tariq said that wasn't true. Tariq was lying.
Tariq also claimed that Black immigrant crime isn't counted in immigrant crime statistics. Which was also a lie.
Tariq's "point" that you claim he got right was that Black immigrant crime gets counted in Black crime statistics. But that point doesn't stand because including immigrant crime numbers makes the Black crime rate go DOWN, not up. Literally the exact opposite of Tariq's point.
The guy I was responding to literally said that being born in America was irrelevant, if you are the child of an immigrant you are an immigrant too. And Malcolm's mother was an immigrant, so he was the child of an immigrant. Are you denying that Malcolm X was the child of an immigrant?
You do know the difference between crime TOTALS and crime RATES, right?
And you just proved that you didn't read any of the studies, because if you had you would have seen that most of the illegal latinos in federal lockup are there for immigration violations, not for actual federal crimes. The illegal immigrant crime rate among latinos is less than half of the native crime rate.
So was Malcolm X an immigrant or not? Because like I said, until this discussion I had NEVER heard anyone refer to him as an immigrant, and when I suggested that he would be an immigrant by your definition, multiple people mocked me and one negged me. But now you're admitting that he is an immigrant by your definition, right?
Now, show one person in the entire 7-year history of the Coli who has ever called Malcolm X an "immigrant" or a "half-immigrant". Do people call Biggie an immigrant, even though both of his parents immigrated? Or Busta or KRS-One or any of the others? Do people in TLR ever call Trump an immigrant even though his mother and father's father were both immigrants
Come on now.
Read the studies. They show that immigrant crime is lower than native crime across all races, and since Black crime rates are higher than White or Latino crime rates the difference is even larger. Educate yourself, please.