Todd McShay overrating cac quarterbacks again - 2018 edition

[Eye Cue DA COLI GAWD]

I watched his highlight vids last night.

Here's what I came away with.

He's a dual threat, with good speed, good arm strength.....BUT he's playing against the sisters of the poor talent wise. He's clearly bigger, faster more athletic than the other guys. It looked like a high school highlight reel.

Now translate that and put Deshaun Watson in his place, and Watson puts up even better numbers. Josh Allen looks good the way some of those Boise St kids looked really good few years ago. But that doesn't mean he's worthy of a top pick.

He's not running over, around power 5 D1 players every week like he is in Wyoming.

I saw enough to see he's not trash like Gabbert etc, but he's basically playing subpar talent every week

Allen threw 5 INTs in a blowout game against Nebraska

"Bu..bu..but Kizer threw two INT against Stanford and got benched in a 17-10 game.

 

[Frump]

Neither Trubisky or Watson is making this throw

I have no idea if he's gonna be a good pro but this is why he's a higher ranked prospect then others

 

[Remote]

Neither Trubisky or Watson is making this throw

I have no idea if he's gonna be a good pro but this is why he's a higher ranked prospect then others

Meaningless.

 

[El Bombi]

How many Big Bens you seeing in the league doing their thing?

Even Tom Brady bytch ass went to Michigan.

These were probably the same dudes that said Cam Newton was going to be trash in the NFL.

That Blaine Gabbert and Jake Locker showed a better skill set than Cam Newton in college.

 

[El Bombi]

Meaningless.

Dude is -1,950 for a reason breh.

 

[Frump]

Meaningless.

So is Watson carving up the Bama defense for the pro level

 

[Frump]

These were probably the same dudes that said Cam Newton was going to be trash in the NFL.

That Blaine Gabbert and Jake Locker showed a better skill set than Cam Newton in college.

So you're saying Watsons got Cam level talent

 

[STAN JONES]

These were probably the same dudes that said Cam Newton was going to be trash in the NFL.

That Blaine Gabbert and Jake Locker showed a better skill set than Cam Newton in college.

Nope

Cam is the best qb prospect to come out this decade IMO

Trying to compare him Watson just shows you don't know real talent when you see it

 

[STAN JONES]

Meaningless.

Yeah showing that you can make a 50 yard throw on a rope running to your left is meaningless but college stats aren't

Yall dudes are hilarious

 

[Rekkapryde]

Cam is the best qb prospect to come out this decade IMO

Andrew Luck

 

[Frump]

Nope

Cam is the best qb prospect to come out this decade IMO

Trying to compare him Watson just shows you don't know real talent when you see it

There's a few people here using this comparison anytime a white qb is picked at the top of the draft now

There gonna do the same comparison when Darnolds picked ahead of Lamar Jackson next year

"Y'all the same dudes who thought Gabbert was better then Cam"

 

[Remote]

Yeah showing that you can make a 50 yard throw on a rope running to your left is meaningless but college stats aren't

Yall dudes are hilarious

What he showed was 56% passing against Division 2 level talent.

Run tell dat.

 

[brother walt]

I Cant want for my boy lamar Jackson to get drafted next year best qb since vick

I might cop this

 

[STAN JONES]

Andrew Luck

Hes the 2nd best qb prospect this decade IMO but i dont have a problem if you say Luck was the better prospect

They both were elite qb prospects

As far as qb prospects coming out of college this decade its

1.Cam
2.Luck
3.Jameis
4.Marriota

Those 4 are the only elite qb prospects to come out this decade IMO

Josh Allen will be the 5th

 

[Frump]

Hes the 2nd best qb prospect this decade IMO but i dont have a problem if you say Luck was the better prospect

They both were elite qb prospects

As far as qb prospects coming out of college this decade its

1.Cam
2.Luck
3.Jameis
4.Marriota

Those 4 are the only elite qb prospects to come out this decade IMO

Josh Allen will be the 5th

Yeah in terms of grades Luck got the highest since Elway I think