Tom Brady First QB In NFL History With 100 More Wins Than Losses

[Carlos Huerta]

Peyton statistically is better in almost every single category than Brady, so that was a

Peyton performs better in the playoffs as is evidenced by his better playoff passer rating and stats

and he ran thru Brady in the biggest comeback in championship history to win a ring more recently, meanwhile Brady has put up some of the biggest chokejobs in NFL history in the same time frame

please tell me where I wrote something that was incorrect

 

[Carlos Huerta]

Now regular season statistics


Tom Brady, 11 seasons (136-39 career record, 78%) 37 game winning drives
96.6 rating, 3798-5948 (64%), 44806 yards, 334 TD, 123 INT, 7.7 AY/A, 5.6 TD%, 2.1 INT%
Per Game: 22-34, 256 yards, 1.9 TD, 0.7 INT
Per Season: 345-541, 4073 yards, 30 touchdowns, 11 interceptions

Peyton Manning, 14 seasons (154-70 career record, 69%) 49 game winning drives
95.7 rating, 5082-7793 (65%), 59487 yards, 436 TD, 209 INT, 7.5 AY/A, 5.6 TD%, 2.7 INT%
Per Game: 23-35, 265 yards, 1.9 TD, 0.9 INT
Per Season: 363-557, 4249 yards, 31 touchdowns, 15 interceptions


Outdoors

Manning (112 games) - 93.3 rating, 2629-4049, 64.9%, 30350 yards, 205 touchdowns, 107 interceptions (1.9 ratio)
Per game: 23-36, 271 yards, 1.8 touchdown, 1.0 interceptions

Brady (163 games) - 96.1 rating, 3509-5528, 63.5%, 41184 yards, 305 touchdowns, 110 interceptions (2.8 ratio)
Per game: 22-34, 253 yards, 1.9 touchdowns, 0.7 interceptions

Similar theme like always, near equal amount of TD's on a game to game/season to season basis just one guy throws more Interceptions(Peyton).

This is with near equal Passer ratings/Completion percentages/YPA's. Peyton doesn't have a stat argument over Brady. This is important because that's what they've based their entire argument on for 10 years(while at the same time Brady having the PS edge as well which I pointed out earlier in this thread)

this will be ignored.. or maybe you'll get a or for emphasis..

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

this will be ignored.. or maybe you'll get a or for emphasis..

all he did was quote peyton having better stats in every category

why would I ignore that?

 

[FTBS]

Imagine if the most prolific offense could have bested 17 pts or Brady hit Moss after he beat double coverage twice in 07 or the 3rd most prolific offense could have bested 21 and Brady had made a better throw to Welker in 11?

There would be no argument at all.

Fixed

Thats such a silly concept. If stuff outside of his control goes his way that somehow makes him better? If he's GOAT then he's GOAT, it doesn't matter how many SBs he wins.

 

[Brozay]

i havent read a post in this thread, because IM SURE its the same, tired ass Peyton/Brady debates

BUT

winning damn near 80% of your games is insane

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

i havent read a post in this thread, because IM SURE its the same, tired ass Peyton/Brady debates

BUT

winning damn near 80% of your games is insane

yes he was on some great teams

individuals don't win rings, as evidenced by Brady having zero since he's become a servicable QB

 

[JLova]

I can't take anyone seriously who calls Brady the GOAT with a straight face.

 

[Brozay]

I can't take anyone seriously who calls Brady the GOAT with a straight face.

Who are your acceptable answers?

 

[JLova]

Who are your acceptable answers?

 

[Brozay]

What makes Montana the GOAT? What separates him from Brady so much that its a laughable discussion?

 

[Carlos Huerta]

all he did was quote peyton having better stats in every category

why would I ignore that?

you must've missed this part -- "This is with near equal Passer ratings/Completion percentages/YPA's. Peyton doesn't have a stat argument over Brady."

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

you must've missed this part -- "This is with near equal Passer ratings/Completion percentages/YPA's. Peyton doesn't have a stat argument over Brady."

there is no such thing as "near equal" one person has a better passer rating and completion percentage than the other. And yards, and touchdowns. These are individual measurements not team stats. Peyton is better in all categories, miss me with this near equal mess

 

[Carlos Huerta]

there is no such thing as "near equal" one person has a better passer rating and completion percentage than the other. And yards, and touchdowns. These are individual measurements not team stats. Peyton is better in all categories, miss me with this near equal mess

Where do you get your numbers from? My sources tell me Brady's QB rating is 96.3, Manning 96.1.

 

[BezO]

Sounds like a team/organization accomplishment to me. No way I give that much credit to one player in the biggest team sport.

Brady is nice, but more goes into being the GOAT.

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

Where do you get your numbers from? My sources tell me Brady's QB rating is 96.3, Manning 96.1.

what do your sources say those playoff passer ratings are, since y'all value playoff performance so much?