I was gonna create another thread to discuss the failures of American soccer (football), but I guess this thread will do.
As far as player development, the USMNT program and MLS academies are absolutely shyt at developing players outside of goalkeepers... and the keepers need polishing too. This falls back on the coaches at these academies. Whether these academies are hiring domestic coaches or foreign ones..... THEY ARE shyt!!!! They are shyt because they cannot train teach and train players good footy habits which improves footy IQ.... WHICH IS 100% OF THE PROBLEM, WHICH IS WHY THE USMNT COULDN'T SECURE QUALIFICATION AGAINST A TEAM THAT HADN'T HAD A WIN IN 9 GAMES UNTIL TODAY. Everyone, including myself, thought the USMNT program has turned the corner because of the high profile victories of the 2000's, the Dempsey/Donovan era, but it has CLEARLY regressed to unorganized, untalented kickball.
Sending players to Europe isn't the best solution either. Most of them CANNOT handle the rigors of professional football... and like most players, they'll ride the pine (bench) for European, South American, African, and even Asian players who are superior to anything (besides GK's) the US produces.
You want results.... Send the coaches to Europe to learn the game and EVERYTHING about it. Positions, their technical skills and their responsibilities; Formations and tactical strategies, etc. Study that shyt for YEARS... Like a minimum of 3-5 years. Then bring that info back to teach the players and train other coaches (as they do in college/professional football and their coaching trees).
The redistribution of athletic talent needs to happen in the US if they want to get serious about competition on the world football stage. You can have the most intelligent team ever assembled... and that team will be undone by a team who that has a few players has that same footy IQ AND WORLD CLASS athleticism. Spain's defense was unbreakable during their World Cup run because of one man who not only had the footy IQ, but he also had good speed and world class leaping ability.... and he was 5'11.... average (my height). Carles Puyol. World class athlete aren't only between 6'0-6'6. The USSF needs to start finding them before football coaches do. Only the US thinks any forward that we have, including Jozy Altidore, is servicable. We've had bad luck with injuries, but many of them are inconsistent for either/and/or club and country. Samuel E'to and Didier Drogba... THOSE ARE FORWARDS.
These are the main reasons why US soccer is shyt.... and regressing daily.