USSInsiders
Banned
Couldn't agree more - would you say it's patently ridiculous for someone to claim that K-Mart is a better player and can provide more on court than him? Would you also say it's ridiculous for someone to say Johnson is expected to be the main factor in helping this Heat team win a title - e.g. is it ridiculous that someone would use how many games (and who) the Heat lose, against Johnson as if he's not doing his job?
To the K-mart thing: yeah, not even close. K-mart was never anywhere near effective as Joe. Martin is just a chucker that provides very little else on the court, and he can't really create his own shot like Joe can. As far as skilled scorers, Joe Johnson has always been at the top of the league, not in the "A-tier" of great scorers like Wade, Kobe, but he has a complete offensive game. He can shoot off the dribble, spot-up, post-up, finish at the rim, etc. Just a complete offensive player.
Martin is more of a spot-up, catch-and-shoot type of guy, and at this stage in his career he can barely do that with much effectiveness.
To latter part of your post: That's debatable, really. They need him to push them over the edge. At the same time, no Bosh makes things extremely difficult but pinning your hopes on a past-his-prime, scoring guard who doesn't really offer much else but offense is a bit much. Regardless, he does play a very important role, but he has the luxury of not having to take too much blame if the team falls short, which it definitely will.

