Was Moonlight better than Birth of a Nation?

rantanamo

All Star
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
4,363
Reputation
490
Daps
8,012
Reppin
NULL
have seen neither. If I had no context or idea about either movie, which would be better?
 

Woman of god

Banned
Joined
Dec 2, 2015
Messages
4,642
Reputation
1,110
Daps
15,816
I didn't see moonlight but BOAN was docile as fukk to be a movie about a slave rebellion. They gave more screen time to the white masters abusing slaves than they did to the actual rebellion. Controversy or not BOAN was very underwhelming, especially given the subject matter. There really wasn't that much distinction between BOAN and 12 years a slave, save for the last 5 min. Django was more of a slave rebellion movie than that
 

WHIPPEDCream

♔Evil Queen.
Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Messages
4,619
Reputation
-6,854
Daps
7,711
Reppin
The Seven Five
I'm going to go see Moonlight for the second time tomorrow.

I love Moonlight because it showcases the perspective of a gay black man, which we never get to see.The concept was wonderful but I'm not going to lie, it fell short.There was not enough depth to the story.It should of had a gay sex scene.
 

Dwolf

Veteran
Joined
Oct 29, 2012
Messages
35,577
Reputation
9,585
Daps
107,268
Reppin
Murim
I didn't like either one of em :manny:
I'm going to go see Moonlight for the second time tomorrow.

I love Moonlight because it showcases the perspective of a gay black man, which we never get to see.The concept was wonderful but I'm not going to lie, it fell short.There was not enough depth to the story.It should of had a gay sex scene.
:dead:
 

brother walt

GOOD AND CHEAP PODCAST
Supporter
Joined
Feb 7, 2015
Messages
10,507
Reputation
3,735
Daps
38,739
Reppin
GOOD AND CHEAP PODCAST
I didn't see moonlight but BOAN was docile as fukk to be a movie about a slave rebellion. They gave more screen time to the white masters abusing slaves than they did to the actual rebellion. Controversy or not BOAN was very underwhelming, especially given the subject matter. There really wasn't that much distinction between BOAN and 12 years a slave, save for the last 5 min. Django was more of a slave rebellion movie than that
this is true i thought he was going to be killing white folks like crazy shyt i was in the movies happy as shyt
 

SirBiatch

Prince of Persia. Stalked for daps
Joined
Feb 18, 2015
Messages
25,121
Reputation
-20,546
Daps
39,874
Just saw Moonlight. Overrated as fukk.

Of course it's the movie everyone's dikkriding. Poverty porn + black homosexuality > slave rebellion.

Birth of a Nation was flawed, but definitely the better film (better script and directing, hands down). And frankly, what Nate Parker pulled off independently on a tiny budget is remarkable.

Just goes to show you - most people are still threatened by slavery and tackling racism head on.
 

#SOG_soldier

New York knicks and phoenix suns stan
Joined
Dec 11, 2014
Messages
22,501
Reputation
2,839
Daps
49,062
Reppin
Chicago, IL
I didn't see moonlight but BOAN was docile as fukk to be a movie about a slave rebellion. They gave more screen time to the white masters abusing slaves than they did to the actual rebellion. Controversy or not BOAN was very underwhelming, especially given the subject matter. There really wasn't that much distinction between BOAN and 12 years a slave, save for the last 5 min. Django was more of a slave rebellion movie than that
Django is a spaghetti western. The goat director has said this multiple times
 

Sukairain

Shahenshah
Joined
Dec 20, 2015
Messages
4,766
Reputation
2,273
Daps
17,363
Reppin
Straiya
I didn't really feel Birth of a Nation like that :manny: the religiousness of it was difficult for me to accept. I wasn't trying to hear that bible talk :childplease:

It was a pretty good movie besides that. Really painful to watch the brutal treatment slaves were subjected to :mjcry: so it is definitely an important film in recording and depicting the ugly truth.
 

Piff Perkins

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
48,716
Reputation
18,140
Daps
262,799
Moonlight is great, very well directed and shot. Haven't seen BOAN yet but I'm looking forward to it.
 

Poitier

My Words Law
Supporter
Joined
Jul 30, 2013
Messages
69,412
Reputation
15,429
Daps
246,362
Moonlight is one of the best films I've seen in the past few.

Its not poverty porn nor is it a gay film. If you got that from watching it then you aren't too bright. The film is about how societal pressures impact identity...the protagonist just happened to be gay.
 

BrothaZay

Non-FBA. AdosK
Bushed
Supporter
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
61,269
Reputation
4,335
Daps
203,758
Reppin
The suburbs
Yes

Birth of A Nation was trash


I don't see how anyone can think Moonlight wasn't the better movie lol
 

BrothaZay

Non-FBA. AdosK
Bushed
Supporter
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
61,269
Reputation
4,335
Daps
203,758
Reppin
The suburbs
Just saw Moonlight. Overrated as fukk.

Of course it's the movie everyone's dikkriding. Poverty porn + black homosexuality > slave rebellion.

Birth of a Nation was flawed, but definitely the better film (better script and directing, hands down). And frankly, what Nate Parker pulled off independently on a tiny budget is remarkable.

Just goes to show you - most people are still threatened by slavery and tackling racism head on.
Better directing? :mjlol: You're biased
 

scarlxrd

Underground
Supporter
Joined
Nov 8, 2014
Messages
13,861
Reputation
7,835
Daps
54,595
Tried to watch Moonlight three times, can't get past the first 15-20 minutes.

shyt's bukkake :trash:
 
Top