Was Prodigy a better lyricst than Andre 3000?

P or 3k?

  • Prodigy

    Votes: 48 58.5%

  • Andre 3k

    Votes: 34 41.5%
  • Total voters
    82
L $ C

L $ C

Superstar
Joined
Jan 27, 2015
Messages
11,092
Reputation
1,637
Daps
23,950
Art Barr said:
When.

Dre 3k never served and was never gon serve nobody.

The problem with y'all is.
Y'all give props for the least common studio plant rap denominator.

Wnat does 3k do that was already done better by others. Before 3k even debuted.

Introspection.
Man fukk all that soft ass shyt. To cpver up you not gon serve nobody.

If i need all that heavy introspection.

I can go listen to a debut solo classic by oc.

Where at least.
i know an emcee was gon get ripped on times up.

plus maybe said artist had help from group input. If i wanna hear all this introspection.

Also like real talk.


all this talk a out dre3k but real talk. Didr so anemiac on the mic past soft shyt. There is not one instrumental of any song ever used that.
someone will request to rhyme on. Plus if a dj put that weak shyt on. The dj would be called supa wack and probably not get many calls. after to host emcee shyt ever again.

You keep making all these weak ass replies with no actual anything substantiative. To back up your answers which are clearly wrong.


Art Barr
Click to expand...
Art that sounds good. Andree has better verses I would argue by far if we want to talk skills flows depth and all. P never spit a verse like Andre in aquemini or 13th floor or sixteen or tons of answers.


P is one of my fav all time too. He’s in my top 5 all time.
 
Robbie3000

Robbie3000

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
32,595
Reputation
6,510
Daps
145,186
Reppin
NULL
How Sway? said:
Dude tried to squeeze the dmv In There :mjlol:

As if they don't only have like 5 rappers to ever break nationally. :mjlol:

Nikka, Outlast would've been GODS in dc if they came from there.


All that said.....prodigy is up there with nas, Jay z and biggie imo. If he was strictly a solo artist, he'd consistently be in most people's top 10 all time. I don't think dre can compete with prodigy like that.
Click to expand...

Aside from HNIC, anything P did solo wise was wack af. Also, he wasn’t even the best rapper in Mobb Deep after HNIC.

I would also argue 300 had far surpassed P as a rapper by the time they each dropped their 3rd group albums.

P is not fukking with 3000 in any way shape or form by the time Murder Music and Aquameni dropped.
 
J

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
26,151
Reputation
4,309
Daps
49,911
Reppin
NULL
And this Andre 3000 getting his Prodigy on:

Hey, winter, spring, summer or fall, I don't stall
Slow drag wit' your brain against the wall
Yeah, nikka, naw, we learn to the side don't fall
All y'all, fukk boys
Tuck toys inside your pants
Just to pull it out, point it at the ground
And make a nikka wanna dance
Now what that be for, you're on that reefer and on that 2Pac
In front of them ooh wops
Tryin' to show out that's the hoe route
Talkin' loud, talkin' 'bout that's gangsta shyt
 
Monoblock

Monoblock

Smoooth
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
31,601
Reputation
10,920
Daps
123,078
Reppin
Houston
Lyrically hell no and I love P but 3K goes to levels lyrically that can't be touched. Verses be a whole story with emotions, ups and downs in life and leaves you stuck. He just different IMO and really they both are. Almost too different to compare.
 
Y

yourgod

Pro
Joined
Jul 29, 2013
Messages
256
Reputation
210
Daps
926
P is in my personal top 5 but even at his best he ain’t seeing 3 stacks. I put Andre in that alien tier of rappers with nas, black thought, pharaoh….they just too good across the board.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top