Where do you rank Gronk all-time?

[Cyber]

He's the best from a talent/ability standpoint. For me to consider him the GOAT he needs to do this longer, something to be said for constantly dominating year in and year out the way Tony G did

 

[Roid Jones]

Witten better than Gronk?

 

[filial_piety]

Showing my age here...but I'm not sure he cracks my top 5...

In No order...

Kellen Winslow
Brent Jones
Keith Jackson
Jay Novecek
Tony Gonzalez

Special rep to Ben Coates.

He's really good with plenty of time left, but I never saw him as dominant as those guys...

 

[JLova]

Jut needs to do it for 5+ more seasons. Longevity is a big factor.

 

[JLova]

Showing my age here...but I'm not sure he cracks my top 5...

In No order...

Kellen Winslow
Brent Jones
Keith Jackson
Jay Novecek
Tony Gonzalez

Special rep to Ben Coates.

He's really good with plenty of time left, but I never saw him as dominant as those guys...

 

[Juggalo Fred]

Witten better than Gronk?

 

[Ineedmoney504]

Showing my age here...but I'm not sure he cracks my top 5...

In No order...

Kellen Winslow
Brent Jones
Keith Jackson
Jay Novecek
Tony Gonzalez

Special rep to Ben Coates.

He's really good with plenty of time left, but I never saw him as dominant as those guys...

he is just as dominating or more honestly. None of those players are the perfect combo of everything like him skill wise

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

Jason Witten is better than Gronk simply for the fact that Witten could catch AND block.

Gronk is borderline useless as a blocker...which is the primary job of a TE to begin with.

:dempsee:

 

[Ronnie Lott]

Tony Gon was great but He wasn't as double and tripled teamed as Gronk is. Gronk is a better blocker, he Blocks like a lineman and Catches/Run the Same Routes as wide receivers. Theres not One player in the league that can go 1 on 1 and Stop him, the only way to stop him is putting him in bubble wrap and not going to him to save him for the playoffs or them Dirty Bronco Defensive backs constantly going at his knees.

Ton

Are you really complaining about how Gronk is tackled?

You can't hit him high in this day of football

 

[Ronnie Lott]

Hes obviously best ever as far as pure talent however you can't rank him #1 due to longetivity. Every play with Gronk you're holding your breath hoping his knee doesnt get fukked up again. When you're that injury prone it is a mark against you. I dont remember Tony G having any serious injuries in his prime.

 

[PremierDaTruth]

A whole lot of people in here that clearly don't know shyt

 

[Dusty Bake Activate]

Showing my age here...but I'm not sure he cracks my top 5...

In No order...

Kellen Winslow
Brent Jones
Keith Jackson
Jay Novecek
Tony Gonzalez

Special rep to Ben Coates.

He's really good with plenty of time left, but I never saw him as dominant as those guys...

How you got Brent Jones, Jay Novacek, and Keith Jackson, but no Shannon Sharpe and Antonio Gates?

 

[Dusty Bake Activate]

Jason Witten is better than Gronk simply for the fact that Witten could catch AND block.

Gronk is borderline useless as a blocker...which is the primary job of a TE to begin with.

Gronk does block, what are you talking about? Lol people don't watch games.

 

[Pimp]

He's the most talented TE I've seen but I would have him at about 5 of all time.

I still think

Tony Gonzalez
Antonio Gates
Shannon Sharpe
Jason Witten

are better but could finish at the top 3 at this rate.

no.. not one of them are better and it's not even close.

 

[Copy Ninja]

Gronk is the Randy Moss of TE as far as having physically dominant skill set

If Moss had been with Brady his entire career he would have destroyed all records