Where does Jason Kidd rank among the All-time great Point guards

[How Sway?]

I got Oscar Robertson, Magic, and John Stockton, above him but he's definitely top 5 easily!



@ this game

EDIT: I'd have him and Nate Archibald sharing the number 4 spot

 

[Shogun]

fukk Jason Kidd

 

[BXKingPin82]

he's top 10 in my opinion
no order
Magic
Big O
Zeke
Kidd
Archibald
Stockton
Walt Clyde Frazier
Payton
Nash
Mark Jackson

 

[stepbackj34spud]

Overrated pos

 

[gho3st]

isaiah thomas

Gary Payton

honorable mention: Walt Frazier

*wait for some sucka to in here and say Iverson...

 

[How Sway?]

fukk Jason Kidd

:thahell:

 

[MooseMouthMthafuga]

he's top 10 in my opinion
no order
Magic
Big O
Zeke
Kidd
Archibald
Stockton
Walt Clyde Frazier
Payton
Nash
Mark Jackson

I'd put Kevin Johnson, Tim Hardaway, and Rod Strickland on that list before Mark Jackson

 

[How Sway?]

isaiah thomas

Gary Payton

honorable mention: Walt Frazier

*wait for some sucka to in here and say Iverson...

I'll give you Isaiah Thomas,

Gary Payton though That one is tough. They're so similar.

Payton was a better scorer(marginally) and better at defense (kidd was a very good defender as well) ,

but Kidd was a better passer and was a better rebounder, and a better 3 point shooter.

This is tough. I'm still going with kidd by a hair though. ESP Since he was able to take the garbage Nets to the finals.

 

[BXKingPin82]

I'd put Kevin Johnson, Tim Hardaway, and Rod Strickland on that list before Mark Jackson

lotta ill guards that played
I probably would take Jackson off too and put Tim Bug on my list

 

[AJtheOne]

top 5

fukk that nikka tho

 

[TheNig]

 

[big bun]

My top-3:

Magic
J Kidd
Zeke

GP number 4

 

[Amare's Right Hook]

Top 5 easy

 

[LesterDiamond]

I might have to put him top 5 honestly.

 

[kash10003]

nikkas saying top 5 like it was debated

In my lifetime it's Magic, Stockton, Kidd and then the rest