Where does Jason Kidd rank among the All-time great Point guards

[BXKingPin82]

List is invalid wit Mark Jackson being on there. He's not even a top 50 PG

replace him with someone

 

[CrimsonTider]

I got Oscar Robertson, Magic, and John Stockton, above him but he's definitely top 5 easily!



@ this game

EDIT: I'd have him and Nate Archibald sharing the number 4 spot

he's top 10 in my opinion
no order
Magic
Big O
Zeke
Kidd
Archibald
Stockton
Walt Clyde Frazier
Payton
Nash
Mark Jackson

5th after Magic, Big O, Stockton and Zeke

List is invalid wit Mark Jackson being on there. He's not even a top 50 PG

Y'all never seen Oscar Robertson Play. Please stop

 

[torcher]

Y'all never seen Oscar Robertson Play. Please stop

Where did I mention Oscar Robertson?

 

[CrimsonTider]

Where did I mention Oscar Robertson?

Didn't mean to quote you.

You are a gentleman and scholar

 

[BXKingPin82]

Y'all never seen Oscar Robertson Play. Please stop

well no shyt
lemme replace that muthafukka with Mookie Blaylock then
smart ass cpt obvious ass nikka

 

[Jesus Shuttlesworth]

He's up there. Triple double machine.

Most amazing stat ever is him being top 3 in 3 pointers made. I remember when that nikka couldn't shoot at all.

 

[Carlos Huerta]

Kidd was a terrible shooter for most of his prime, mediocre scorer, and because of it was a non threat in the half court offense. Yes he was an elite defender but PG is an offensive first position.

He did nothing of note in the WCF as a franchise player. It wasn't until he went to a historically bad conference where he started to have success in the PS

Just an overall dumb, misinformed response.
























Jesus

 

[torcher]

No lower then top 5

 

[CrimsonTider]

well no shyt
lemme replace that muthafukka with Mookie Blaylock then
smart ass cpt obvious ass nikka

Why can't it be understood that you are only considering players you seen play in YOUR rankings.

Ranking players you haven't seen is unfair to the conversation, that player and other players.

Y'all do that shyt because you think your suppose to.

 

[Street Knowledge]

Just an overall dumb, misinformed response.
























Jesus

What did I say that wasnt true?

 

[BXKingPin82]

Why can't it be understood that you are only considering players you seen play in YOUR rankings.

Ranking players you haven't seen is unfair to the conversation, that player and other players.

Y'all do that shyt because you think your suppose to.

Hey look... if that were the criteria for this shyt I would do that.
Where in the thread title do you see "Where does Jason Kidd rank among point guards YOU ACTUALLY SAW PLAY?"

Whats wrong with you? Always someone wanting to squeeze a fukkin lemon.

do I have to reset? will that cheer you up? petty ass shyt

 

[Street Knowledge]

Also kidd supporters why were the offenses he led mostly mediocre to trash?

2000 suns:16th in ORTG
2001 Suns: 22nd in ORTG
2002 Nets: 17th in ORTG
2003 Nets: 18th in ORTG
2004 Nets: 25th in ORTG
2005 Nets: 26th in ORTG
2006 Nets: 25Th in ORTG
2007 Nets: 16th in ORTG

 

[Point Blank]

What did I say that wasnt true?

Breh, Kidd's game wasn't meant to be on offensive threat. We all know this.. He was a pass first PG and made his teammates better. How does that transcend to being overrated?

 

[NatiboyB]

J Kidd is in my top 6

Magic
Stockton
Isiah
O
Kidd
Payton
Paul

 

[Point Blank]

Also kidd supporters why were the offenses he led mostly mediocre to trash?

2000 suns:16th in ORTG
2001 Suns: 22nd in ORTG
2002 Nets: 17th in ORTG
2003 Nets: 18th in ORTG
2004 Nets: 25th in ORTG
2005 Nets: 26th in ORTG
2006 Nets: 25Th in ORTG
2007 Nets: 16th in ORTG

Offensively, those rosters weren't all that great.